Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

What makes a leather jacket fit “right” in the shoulders?

jerryoldiee

New in Town
Messages
21
Been reading a few threads here lately where the shoulders and sleeves feel too big even when the chest size is right. For those who’ve bought online, what do you check first: shoulder seam placement, sleeve length, or chest ease? And how much do you trust break-in to fix a slightly loose fit?
 

onstar

A-List Customer
Messages
427
Location
Jo Mammas House
Been reading a few threads here lately where the shoulders and sleeves feel too big even when the chest size is right. For those who’ve bought online, what do you check first: shoulder seam placement, sleeve length, or chest ease? And how much do you trust break-in to fix a slightly loose fit?


Im not overly concerned with the shoulders. For me it would the the chest and arm hole width
 

jerryoldiee

New in Town
Messages
21
Im not overly concerned with the shoulders. For me it would the the chest and arm hole width
Thanks onstar, that’s helpful. When you say arm hole width, do you mean how snug it feels when you raise your arms, or how much room there is for layering underneath?
 

Tom71

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,093
Location
Europe
Im not overly concerned with the shoulders. For me it would the the chest and arm hole width

Seconded. Chest is non-negotiable. A jacket that is too tight in the chest (or abdomen) will never fit comfortably, and no amount of break-in will create noteworthy extra-room.

Shoulder can be a nuisance if too narrow, but there is some leeway, as your shoulders can simply use part of the sleeve as extra-room.

If the armholes get to narrow, layering will become an issue. Some users also report comfort-issue with to wide armholes as there can be a lot of pull on the upper sleeves when raising your arms. I have only ever experienced any issues when ill-fitting armholes come without any movement support such as gussets, action-backs or underarm-footballs (my favourite).
 

AeroFan_07

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,269
Location
Iowa
Seconded. Chest is non-negotiable. A jacket that is too tight in the chest (or abdomen) will never fit comfortably, and no amount of break-in will create noteworthy extra-room.

Shoulder can be a nuisance if too narrow, but there is some leeway, as your shoulders can simply use part of the sleeve as extra-room.

If the armholes get to narrow, layering will become an issue. Some users also report comfort-issue with to wide armholes as there can be a lot of pull on the upper sleeves when raising your arms. I have only ever experienced any issues when ill-fitting armholes come without any movement support such as gussets, action-backs or underarm-footballs (my favourite).
This has been my experience as well

I always like when shoulders "fall" correctly at the sleeve & shoulder joint. however slightly more or less is not a large deal to me compared to pit-to-pit misses, which makes the jacket un-wearable if too small, or ballon-like if too large (see photos of nearly any 1990's mall jackets). :)
 
Last edited:

TNas

New in Town
Messages
14
Agree that chest fit should be one of the main priorities. You can definitely get away with the shoulder measurements being a bit off, but one additional thing to look out for when it comes to sleeves especially for the thicker leather jackets is the pit to hem length. If it's too long, the jacket will hike up when you sit and it'll jam up into your armpit which feels very annoying.
 

TartuWolf

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,721
Location
Tartu, Estonia
I'm on the other side of the fence than some of the others here.

Unless shoulders are pretty spot on (within ~3-4cm tolerance) it will either be uncomfortable and tight or look bad (too wide). Usually I go for ~42-45cm shoulders.
Anything around 42cm or even less has always started to feel restrictive, although upper back width can very much make it worse or alleviate the issue.
I had one coat with 47-48cm shoulders and while it felt good I just couldn't accept the dropped shoulder look that I deeply dislike because I associate it with modern sloppy/baggy fits.
And that's also the whole reason I will probably never try any shearling jackets (B-3,B-6,RAF and the like) - they always have dropped shoulders.

Also very important to mention that chest is not the same as pit-to-pit width.
What I consider chest width is seam to seam (armhole) somewhere midway between pit to pit and and shoulders.
I've had jackets with the same pit-to-pit but different chest widths, which completely makes or breaks the jacket for me.
It's the front equivalent to upper back width, which (together with shoulder width) can make or brake how the jacket feels if it's too tight.
 

jerryoldiee

New in Town
Messages
21
I'm on the other side of the fence than some of the others here.

Unless shoulders are pretty spot on (within ~3-4cm tolerance) it will either be uncomfortable and tight or look bad (too wide). Usually I go for ~42-45cm shoulders.
Anything around 42cm or even less has always started to feel restrictive, although upper back width can very much make it worse or alleviate the issue.
I had one coat with 47-48cm shoulders and while it felt good I just couldn't accept the dropped shoulder look that I deeply dislike because I associate it with modern sloppy/baggy fits.
And that's also the whole reason I will probably never try any shearling jackets (B-3,B-6,RAF and the like) - they always have dropped shoulders.

Also very important to mention that chest is not the same as pit-to-pit width.
What I consider chest width is seam to seam (armhole) somewhere midway between pit to pit and and shoulders.
I've had jackets with the same pit-to-pit but different chest widths, which completely makes or breaks the jacket for me.
It's the front equivalent to upper back width, which (together with shoulder width) can make or brake how the jacket feels if it's too tight.
Thanks all, really helpful. TartuWolf, the chest vs. pit-to-pit distinction is something I hadn’t thought about. When you’re buying online, how do you check that seam-to-seam chest width if the seller only gives pit-to-pit? Do you ask for an extra measurement, or compare against a jacket you already own? Also curious whether you’ve found break-in loosens that upper chest area at all, or if it stays fixed.
 
INTRODUCING THE #HERITAGE2026 CONTEST
Introducing the #Heritage2026 contest by Reversible!

If you’re anything like the textbook Fedora Lounge reader, you’ve already got a few outfits up your sleeve that could earn you a $100 cash prize. So show us what you’ve got.

REVERSIBLE is giving you the chance to win $100 by sharing your best heritage-inspired looks.

There are 10 winners: 4 selected based on the most-liked posts and 6 handpicked by the Fedora Lounge, Styleforum & Heddels teams.

HOW TO ENTER:

1. Sign up on the REVERSIBLE app: https://styleforum.co/4iYurFm

2. Create a post on the REVERSIBLE app, and tag #heritage2026.

That’s it! Show us your denim, boots, workwear, and everything else that makes heritage style your own.

Good luck and happy posting!

- The Fedora Lounge Team

Sponsored Content

Forum statistics

Threads
115,883
Messages
3,200,897
Members
59,440
Latest member
Theinterstellar
Top