- Messages
- 18,221
I would agree with you that the Sherry matured is better than their fine oak. If I am buying a bottle & it is not on deep sale I would add the caveat that there is better whisky at that price point. And I would say the same thing for Highland Park; I like Highland Park just fine but there is better whisky at that price point.The sherry cask Macallans are superior the their Fine Oak offerings. I would never turn down Macallan 12.