Marc mndt
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 7,312
I do like the fit and quality of this Japanese made jacket though
There are custom jean shops that literally copies (insert your current jeans here) in any premium selvage fabric you want. I ran into one in Japan last time I was there. I am sure similar shops are all over the places in Asia, and the prices will differ a lot based on location."Quality" is very subjective. In my mind quality is trumped by pattern and fit.
Let's take jeans, for example. Iron Heart vs Levi's. Iron Heart are phenomenal quality. Their signature fabric is different class, every little detail is wonderfully done, and I have genuinely marvelled at how well made they are. They don't, however, sell a pair of jeans that fit me as well as Levi's 541. They have no competing pattern, and on my body their better options simply don't fit right. Are the Levi's good quality? Sometimes the quality is alright, but more often than not it's a bit disappointing. Variable fabric, variable finishing, heck, variable sizing!! I'd pay for better 541's, and indeed have, when Levi's can be bothered to sell the "Premium" version of the jeans. Whilst better, the Premium is still leagues below Iron Heart in quality. But until a higher quality maker makes jeans with such a good pattern for me, it simply doesn't matter.
Similarly, however good the quality of the Japanese jackets is, it just doesn't matter when you rarely ever see them fit someone (Asian or Western) perfectly.
Which is shown below: the best fitting Mulholland on planet earth.In the end, I look for BOTH fit and quality
I agree. Looks great on you!
I didn't know such shops existed for jeans. That would appeal to me! I tried and failed a few times to get my favourite suit trousers copied precisely- I like a front rise of 11" and a large rear rise of 17-17.5" because I have a big ass from a lifetime of sport and weightlifting, and no one seemed to be able to get their head around how that had been achieved, which was worrying. Time and again I'd end up with a high front rise or a low back rise.There are custom jean shops that literally copies (insert your current jeans here) in any premium selvage fabric you want. I ran into one in Japan last time I was there. I am sure similar shops are all over the places in Asia, and the prices will differ a lot based on location.
Is there a "5Star" for denim yet?
If I may go further. There are different aspects and quality on a garment and each individual would likely place different value on different aspects. Some would place higher value on weight, thickness and some would place more value on other aspects."Quality" is very subjective. In my mind quality is trumped by pattern and fit.
Let's take jeans, for example. Iron Heart vs Levi's. Iron Heart are phenomenal quality. Their signature fabric is different class, every little detail is wonderfully done, and I have genuinely marvelled at how well made they are. They don't, however, sell a pair of jeans that fit me as well as Levi's 541. They have no competing pattern, and on my body their better options simply don't fit right. Are the Levi's good quality? Sometimes the quality is alright, but more often than not it's a bit disappointing. Variable fabric, variable finishing, heck, variable sizing!! I'd pay for better 541's, and indeed have, when Levi's can be bothered to sell the "Premium" version of the jeans. Whilst better, the Premium is still leagues below Iron Heart in quality. But until a higher quality maker makes jeans with such a good pattern for me, it simply doesn't matter.
Similarly, however good the quality of the Japanese jackets is, it just doesn't matter when you rarely ever see them fit someone (Asian or Western) perfectly.
I can only repeat myself (and be ignored); Vanson makes professional motorcycle equipment. Comparing a maker you pretty much trust your life to to a company that only wants you to look good is stupid. Vanson makes a better leather jacket. There's no discussion there and no maker or expert will ever give an edge to FCL.
I can only repeat myself (and be ignored); Vanson makes professional motorcycle equipment. Comparing a maker you pretty much trust your life to to a company that only wants you to look good is stupid. Vanson makes a better leather jacket.
I think what makes the Vanson look better, aside from the fit which is obvious and you seem to admit as much, is a level of authenticity that comes with the Vanson. It can’t be faked or feigned. Your FW will never, and I can assure you, never ever look like that.I am quite happy with the Vanson jacket. Objectively, however, it is unquestionably worse than the Freewheelers jacket. The leather is crappy, the lining is mediocre, and the construction quality is abhorrent. Schott makes better jackets than this and I don't like Schotts. The Freewheelers and RMC have massively superior leather. The Vanson leather is slightly thicker, but hardly so.
Also, I think the FW jacket fits me very well and the RMC would probably fit well in the right size. To suggest that I sell the FW is silly. Also, anyone suggesting I sell the RMC isn't paying attention because I already said I sold it in the first post.
The Vanson looks cooler because:
1. It's a black leather jacket and people generally seem to think those look cooler
2. It fits me ridiculously well. I know Vanson has great patterns and thats why I bought this. Vanson's patterns outdo everything else about their jackets.
3. It's broken in. This is huge. Anyone saying the leather on the Vanson is better is talking rubbish in my opinion. It only appears better because it's broken in. Full stop.
I love this Vanson jacket and it's not going anywhere, but fit does not equal quality.
Additionally, many on here know that I agree that many Japanese makers have atrocious patterns. Fountainhead, FCL, Double Helix, Y2, Flat Head, etc. However, Freewheelers and RMC do fantastic patterns without a doubt. Not all Japanese makers are equal. I think that much is clear.
Even FW isn't perfect as much as I love them. It's very clear at this point that Greg from Field Leathers has the cleanest stitching in the world on leather jackets. It's obvious. I know my La Brea doesn't fit me perfectly, but it fits well and I believe (though I could be wrong) that it will look absolutely amazing when it breaks in.
Well certainly a Vanson is more authentic simply because it is not a vintage repro. I agree it will never look the same simply because the leather is different. Do I believe it's possible that the Freewheelers could one day look better than the Vanson in terms of being worn in? Yes. However, I also understand that the Vanson may never be matched by any of my other garments in this regard. Most likely, nothing I own will ever look as wonderfully beat up as this Vanson.I think what makes the Vanson look better, aside from the fit which is obvious and you seem to admit as much, is a level of authenticity that comes with the Vanson. It can’t be faked or feigned. Your FW will never, and I can assure you, never ever look like that.
My suggestion for selling the FW comes not from a quality standpoint. It is a very high quality piece no doubt, and I never once said otherwise, but the fit is poor. The shoulders are vacant and it’s entirely too long. A cross zip should not fall where it does in the case of your FW. Nor should it appear as tubular through the body. I assume and hopefully rightfully, you can accept these criticisms without taking them as personal insult, but your physique simply does not support this garment.
Of course this is just my two cents and you will do whatever you feel is best. More than anything I’m glad to see you stepped outside your box and wound up with a spectacular jacket.
So then the next step is to get you into some true vintage halfbelts so that you can drop the “almost” from your blog.Well certainly a Vanson is more authentic simply because it is not a vintage repro. I agree it will never look the same simply because the leather is different. Do I believe it's possible that the Freewheelers could one day look better than the Vanson in terms of being worn in? Yes. However, I also understand that the Vanson may never be matched by any of my other garments in this regard. Most likely, nothing I own will ever look as wonderfully beat up as this Vanson.
You and @Monitor are why I wanted a Vanson and I am so glad I was influenced by you guys because this thing is epic and I love it. If I haven't made this clear, despite it's many flaws, I would take this very Vanson over the vast majority of other leather jackets, including the vast majority of Japanese jackets even if you reduced the price of the Japanese jackets to that of this Vanson.
Yes I do accept your fit criticisms and what is more, I appreciate them. I need people to give me harsh critiques of how things fit me. It's very helpful. Personally, I think the jacket looks good on me, especially when zipped up. Does it look as good as the Vanson on me? Not even close. However, the Vanson has the advantage of being broken in and that is huge. I do agree my body does not suit the Freewheelers as well. That said, I still think it looks good now and will get better. If it doesn't, then I may let it go one day.
The vanson is the worse jacket, but it's also the better jacket for me at this moment.
I'll put it this way:
Do I ever see myself thinking the Vanson is objectively better? No. Do I ever see myself preferring it to the FW? Yes absolutely. Do I ever see myself not liking the fit of the Vanson or selling it? No. Do I ever see myself not liking the fit on the Freewheelers or selling it? Yes.
That is a great story, and perhaps not as surprising as one may think. After all, there are plenty of Ford salesman who drive Toyotas and Hondas.I struck up a conversation with him which inter alia included asking which Vanson model he wears. I was surprised by his answer because he said he wears Langlitz. I actually had to ask him to repeat his answer because of his regular Japanese accent. Now I know he rides because we also talked about bikes. I also know he is not Langlitz dealer because he only sells Vanson