Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Five Star Leather Jackets

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
Well, if it's not desired, see if "show business" people might like it; it has some "Bling" factor. IDK; it's not at all like the Military/Indy Jones style of jackets I favor, so I have no useful comments to offer other than the above. We all make mistakes. Best Wishes!
 

coolhandluke_7

One of the Regulars
Messages
230
Location
Oklahoma City, OK
Well, if it's not desired, see if "show business" people might like it; it has some "Bling" factor. IDK; it's not at all like the Military/Indy Jones style of jackets I favor, so I have no useful comments to offer other than the above. We all make mistakes. Best Wishes!

The jacket is based on a Buco J-31. A motorcycle jacket from the late '40s - early 50s. Michael Jackson fans and "show business people" are definitely not the intended buying audience.


j-31---film-stripArtboard-1-copy.png
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
An "Original" Buco J-31 jacket would be worth something. Comparing a 5* User-Defined Replica to an Original is comparing apples to oranges.
 
Last edited:

coolhandluke_7

One of the Regulars
Messages
230
Location
Oklahoma City, OK
An "Original" Buco J-31 jacket would be worth something. Comparing a 5* User-Defined Replica to an Original is comparing apples to oranges.

You seemed unaware that the jacket was based on a J-31, given your Michael Jackson and "show business people" references. I was simply sharing information on the basis of the jacket. That is all.
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
You seemed unaware that the jacket was based on a J-31, given your Michael Jackson and "show business people" references. I was simply sharing information on the basis of the jacket. That is all.

Perhaps I was inexact in wording previous comments, and I apologize for any possible imprecision. OTOH, you may be making unwarranted assumptions.

No offense to previous poster, but the apparently user-defined jacket under discussion (and pictured above) is very far from original J-31.

FWIW, I'm getting a "whiff" of VLJ elitism.
 
Last edited:

Bluechel

One Too Many
Messages
1,344
An "Original" Buco J-31 jacket would be worth something. Comparing a 5* User-Defined Replica to an Original is comparing apples to oranges.
However, attempting to utilize the jacket maker to custom-make whatever you may want is right down the fairway for this discussion. You want an A-2; I was hoping for some kind of Buco J-31 back then (worlds of new wisdom and knowledge later; I know that's not sound). The maker is Five Star...the discussions here are real-world examples being shared along with more granular topics, all within the 5* chain here. At the very least, I would never have made my choice in "goat," as there could never really be a way to artificially (or by real-world "wear and tear") get this to look anything like a J-31....yes, mistakes WERE made. Money was, in my own personal opinion WASTED. Back then, there was no Brake House or something like it that was well-known. We do what we do, and we learn what we like and what is tolerable. Shared experiences here help users to make their own more informed choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: raf

coolhandluke_7

One of the Regulars
Messages
230
Location
Oklahoma City, OK
Perhaps I was inexact in wording previous comments, and I apologize for any possible imprecision. OTOH, you may be making unwarranted assumptions.

No offense to previous poster, but the apparently user-defined jacket under discussion (and pictured above) is very far from original J-31.

FWIW, I'm getting a "whiff" of VFJ elitism.

Sorry...I'm not aware of this VFJ that you speak of.
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
Sorry...I'm not aware of this VFJ that you speak of.

Sorry, Typo on my part and since corrected; I meant VLJ. It's a useful site and lots of info posted there, as well as many well-informed members. Please say "HI!" to the nice folks there.
 
Last edited:

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
10
Custom Leather Jacket from Five Star - let me know your opinion
 

Attachments

  • Image (22).jpg
    Image (22).jpg
    472.4 KB · Views: 27
  • Image (21).jpg
    Image (21).jpg
    387.1 KB · Views: 29
  • Image (20).jpg
    Image (20).jpg
    372.2 KB · Views: 27
  • Image (19).jpg
    Image (19).jpg
    434.3 KB · Views: 31
  • Image (23).jpg
    Image (23).jpg
    462.1 KB · Views: 28
  • Image (24).jpg
    Image (24).jpg
    505.7 KB · Views: 29
  • Image (25).jpg
    Image (25).jpg
    511.3 KB · Views: 32

Nilcolombo

New in Town
Messages
16
Clean silhoette and nice leather, especially for a custom Five Star order! That said , looking at the shoulders and chest ,it looks cut very trim-almost like a showroom mannequi n fit. It looks sharp standing straignt , though I'd wonder how easy it is to raiseyou arms or reach for something without it pulling . Did you intentionall y go for a snug , tailored look?
 

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
10
Clean silhoette and nice leather, especially for a custom Five Star order! That said , looking at the shoulders and chest ,it looks cut very trim-almost like a showroom mannequi n fit. It looks sharp standing straignt , though I'd wonder how easy it is to raiseyou arms or reach for something without it pulling . Did you intentionall y go for a snug , tailored look?
Thanks for checking this out. I went for a snug fit. It is quite comfortable and easy to raise my arms. I had researched a bit about the fit - based on my experience with previous jackets and had ordered 18 inch shoulders with action back - which seems to do the trick. I am able to reach out and move my arms comfortably. The only sore point is the neck snap - it is too tight if closed. I had also asked for matte black leather with all black hardware and two-way zipper.
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,164
Location
Europe

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
10
Funny, it looks like 5* has recreated the jacket I used to have, this time with hand warmers instead of chest pockets. But the rest is the same. And I copied this from a jacket by “Jean Shop New York” and made a few changes.
https://www.thefedoralounge.com/thr...ther-jacket-in-size-small.100690/post-2733184

Your jacket fits well—it’s maybe a tad too long, considering how tight it is at the bottom.
Thanks! Sharp eyes - yes, it is just a tiny bit tight at the bottom - but then it has two way zippers so, can always adjust it - though, not uncomfortable even when zipped all the way. The only gripe is that they made the neck too small - so the neck snap wouldn't fasten without strangling me.
Wearable ?
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,164
Location
Europe
Thanks! Sharp eyes - yes, it is just a tiny bit tight at the bottom - but then it has two way zippers so, can always adjust it - though, not uncomfortable even when zipped all the way. The only gripe is that they made the neck too small - so the neck snap wouldn't fasten without strangling me.
Wearable ?
Visually, it looks better when the collar is tighter rather than looser. The tight collar is probably a result of my order, since I ordered it extra snug. 5* can’t make properly proportioned patterns. They take a pattern and adjust it. And if a measurement was already tight to begin with, it’ll be even tighter in a smaller size.
But I’d say it’s wearable.
But if you plan to actually button up the collar (which I never did), then it probably won’t be wearable.
 

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
10
Visually, it looks better when the collar is tighter rather than looser. The tight collar is probably a result of my order, since I ordered it extra snug. 5* can’t make properly proportioned patterns. They take a pattern and adjust it. And if a measurement was already tight to begin with, it’ll be even tighter in a smaller size.
But I’d say it’s wearable.
But if you plan to actually button up the collar (which I never did), then it probably won’t be wearable.
Thanks. I don't plan on fastening the snap. I obviously cannot return it, so will wear it :)
 
INTRODUCING THE #HERITAGE2026 CONTEST
Introducing the #Heritage2026 contest by Reversible!

If you’re anything like the textbook Fedora Lounge reader, you’ve already got a few outfits up your sleeve that could earn you a $100 cash prize. So show us what you’ve got.

REVERSIBLE is giving you the chance to win $100 by sharing your best heritage-inspired looks.

There are 10 winners: 4 selected based on the most-liked posts and 6 handpicked by the Fedora Lounge, Styleforum & Heddels teams.

HOW TO ENTER:

1. Sign up on the REVERSIBLE app: https://styleforum.co/4iYurFm

2. Create a post on the REVERSIBLE app, and tag #heritage2026.

That’s it! Show us your denim, boots, workwear, and everything else that makes heritage style your own.

Good luck and happy posting!

- The Fedora Lounge Team

Sponsored Content

Forum statistics

Threads
115,929
Messages
3,201,684
Members
59,480
Latest member
Sonofaskipper
Top