Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Five Star Leather Jackets

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
Well, if it's not desired, see if "show business" people might like it; it has some "Bling" factor. IDK; it's not at all like the Military/Indy Jones style of jackets I favor, so I have no useful comments to offer other than the above. We all make mistakes. Best Wishes!
 

coolhandluke_7

One of the Regulars
Messages
230
Location
Oklahoma City, OK
Well, if it's not desired, see if "show business" people might like it; it has some "Bling" factor. IDK; it's not at all like the Military/Indy Jones style of jackets I favor, so I have no useful comments to offer other than the above. We all make mistakes. Best Wishes!

The jacket is based on a Buco J-31. A motorcycle jacket from the late '40s - early 50s. Michael Jackson fans and "show business people" are definitely not the intended buying audience.


j-31---film-stripArtboard-1-copy.png
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
An "Original" Buco J-31 jacket would be worth something. Comparing a 5* User-Defined Replica to an Original is comparing apples to oranges.
 
Last edited:

coolhandluke_7

One of the Regulars
Messages
230
Location
Oklahoma City, OK
An "Original" Buco J-31 jacket would be worth something. Comparing a 5* User-Defined Replica to an Original is comparing apples to oranges.

You seemed unaware that the jacket was based on a J-31, given your Michael Jackson and "show business people" references. I was simply sharing information on the basis of the jacket. That is all.
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
You seemed unaware that the jacket was based on a J-31, given your Michael Jackson and "show business people" references. I was simply sharing information on the basis of the jacket. That is all.

Perhaps I was inexact in wording previous comments, and I apologize for any possible imprecision. OTOH, you may be making unwarranted assumptions.

No offense to previous poster, but the apparently user-defined jacket under discussion (and pictured above) is very far from original J-31.

FWIW, I'm getting a "whiff" of VLJ elitism.
 
Last edited:

Bluechel

One Too Many
Messages
1,344
An "Original" Buco J-31 jacket would be worth something. Comparing a 5* User-Defined Replica to an Original is comparing apples to oranges.
However, attempting to utilize the jacket maker to custom-make whatever you may want is right down the fairway for this discussion. You want an A-2; I was hoping for some kind of Buco J-31 back then (worlds of new wisdom and knowledge later; I know that's not sound). The maker is Five Star...the discussions here are real-world examples being shared along with more granular topics, all within the 5* chain here. At the very least, I would never have made my choice in "goat," as there could never really be a way to artificially (or by real-world "wear and tear") get this to look anything like a J-31....yes, mistakes WERE made. Money was, in my own personal opinion WASTED. Back then, there was no Brake House or something like it that was well-known. We do what we do, and we learn what we like and what is tolerable. Shared experiences here help users to make their own more informed choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: raf

coolhandluke_7

One of the Regulars
Messages
230
Location
Oklahoma City, OK
Perhaps I was inexact in wording previous comments, and I apologize for any possible imprecision. OTOH, you may be making unwarranted assumptions.

No offense to previous poster, but the apparently user-defined jacket under discussion (and pictured above) is very far from original J-31.

FWIW, I'm getting a "whiff" of VFJ elitism.

Sorry...I'm not aware of this VFJ that you speak of.
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
310
Sorry...I'm not aware of this VFJ that you speak of.

Sorry, Typo on my part and since corrected; I meant VLJ. It's a useful site and lots of info posted there, as well as many well-informed members. Please say "HI!" to the nice folks there.
 
Last edited:

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
9
Custom Leather Jacket from Five Star - let me know your opinion
 

Attachments

  • Image (22).jpg
    Image (22).jpg
    472.4 KB · Views: 25
  • Image (21).jpg
    Image (21).jpg
    387.1 KB · Views: 27
  • Image (20).jpg
    Image (20).jpg
    372.2 KB · Views: 26
  • Image (19).jpg
    Image (19).jpg
    434.3 KB · Views: 30
  • Image (23).jpg
    Image (23).jpg
    462.1 KB · Views: 27
  • Image (24).jpg
    Image (24).jpg
    505.7 KB · Views: 28
  • Image (25).jpg
    Image (25).jpg
    511.3 KB · Views: 31

Nilcolombo

New in Town
Messages
16
Clean silhoette and nice leather, especially for a custom Five Star order! That said , looking at the shoulders and chest ,it looks cut very trim-almost like a showroom mannequi n fit. It looks sharp standing straignt , though I'd wonder how easy it is to raiseyou arms or reach for something without it pulling . Did you intentionall y go for a snug , tailored look?
 

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
9
Clean silhoette and nice leather, especially for a custom Five Star order! That said , looking at the shoulders and chest ,it looks cut very trim-almost like a showroom mannequi n fit. It looks sharp standing straignt , though I'd wonder how easy it is to raiseyou arms or reach for something without it pulling . Did you intentionall y go for a snug , tailored look?
Thanks for checking this out. I went for a snug fit. It is quite comfortable and easy to raise my arms. I had researched a bit about the fit - based on my experience with previous jackets and had ordered 18 inch shoulders with action back - which seems to do the trick. I am able to reach out and move my arms comfortably. The only sore point is the neck snap - it is too tight if closed. I had also asked for matte black leather with all black hardware and two-way zipper.
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,164
Location
Europe

thenaughtyone

New in Town
Messages
9
Funny, it looks like 5* has recreated the jacket I used to have, this time with hand warmers instead of chest pockets. But the rest is the same. And I copied this from a jacket by “Jean Shop New York” and made a few changes.
https://www.thefedoralounge.com/thr...ther-jacket-in-size-small.100690/post-2733184

Your jacket fits well—it’s maybe a tad too long, considering how tight it is at the bottom.
Thanks! Sharp eyes - yes, it is just a tiny bit tight at the bottom - but then it has two way zippers so, can always adjust it - though, not uncomfortable even when zipped all the way. The only gripe is that they made the neck too small - so the neck snap wouldn't fasten without strangling me.
Wearable ?
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,164
Location
Europe
Thanks! Sharp eyes - yes, it is just a tiny bit tight at the bottom - but then it has two way zippers so, can always adjust it - though, not uncomfortable even when zipped all the way. The only gripe is that they made the neck too small - so the neck snap wouldn't fasten without strangling me.
Wearable ?
Visually, it looks better when the collar is tighter rather than looser. The tight collar is probably a result of my order, since I ordered it extra snug. 5* can’t make properly proportioned patterns. They take a pattern and adjust it. And if a measurement was already tight to begin with, it’ll be even tighter in a smaller size.
But I’d say it’s wearable.
But if you plan to actually button up the collar (which I never did), then it probably won’t be wearable.
 
INTRODUCING THE #HERITAGE2026 CONTEST
Introducing the #Heritage2026 contest by Reversible!

If you’re anything like the textbook Fedora Lounge reader, you’ve already got a few outfits up your sleeve that could earn you a $100 cash prize. So show us what you’ve got.

REVERSIBLE is giving you the chance to win $100 by sharing your best heritage-inspired looks.

There are 10 winners: 4 selected based on the most-liked posts and 6 handpicked by the Fedora Lounge, Styleforum & Heddels teams.

HOW TO ENTER:

1. Sign up on the REVERSIBLE app: https://styleforum.co/4iYurFm

2. Create a post on the REVERSIBLE app, and tag #heritage2026.

That’s it! Show us your denim, boots, workwear, and everything else that makes heritage style your own.

Good luck and happy posting!

- The Fedora Lounge Team

Sponsored Content

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
115,929
Messages
3,201,677
Members
59,480
Latest member
Sonofaskipper
Top