Hercule
Practically Family
- Messages
- 953
- Location
- Western Reserve (Cleveland)
The following, FAR from trivial in my opinion, did MUCH more than tick me off.
Because we are working parents, our 10yr old son attends a day camp for several weeks during the summer when he isn't enrolled in a more topic/activity oriented camp - chess camp, Natural History museum, chamber music camp etc. This day camp is run by the same organization that ran the daycare/preschool we had him in before he entered kindergarten, so we have a relatively long history with them. At any rate, after I picked my son up yesterday, and when we were in the car on the way home, he tells me that he was scolded for reading! Apparently, they had gotten back from the playground and had an hour to kill before lunch, so they played "around the world", what ever that game is. My son, rather than participating in the game took out his book and began reading, at which point the counselor told him that if he wasn't going to play the game he should put the book away and sit there quietly and do nothing. I went through the roof when I heard this! So this morning when I dropped him off I confronted the counselor about it (being careful to ask another counselor to witness the interaction). Her story wasn't much different from my son's though she denied scolding him for reading. Long story short, I cautioned her that, not only was it my son's prerogative to not participate but that given the universally recognized fundamental place of reading in education, intellectual development and enrichment, and literacy, discouraging children from reading, let alone associating it with punishment by denying or even adding reading time as a punitive measure, is not a good direction to go in. She reluctantly acknowledged she was wrong but easily apologized and I asked that she direct her acknowledgement and apology to my son not me. Which she did. Fortunately he only has today and tomorrow then he's done with them for this summer. Next summer, we are considering that he may be able to stay home by himself at least part of the time.
Because we are working parents, our 10yr old son attends a day camp for several weeks during the summer when he isn't enrolled in a more topic/activity oriented camp - chess camp, Natural History museum, chamber music camp etc. This day camp is run by the same organization that ran the daycare/preschool we had him in before he entered kindergarten, so we have a relatively long history with them. At any rate, after I picked my son up yesterday, and when we were in the car on the way home, he tells me that he was scolded for reading! Apparently, they had gotten back from the playground and had an hour to kill before lunch, so they played "around the world", what ever that game is. My son, rather than participating in the game took out his book and began reading, at which point the counselor told him that if he wasn't going to play the game he should put the book away and sit there quietly and do nothing. I went through the roof when I heard this! So this morning when I dropped him off I confronted the counselor about it (being careful to ask another counselor to witness the interaction). Her story wasn't much different from my son's though she denied scolding him for reading. Long story short, I cautioned her that, not only was it my son's prerogative to not participate but that given the universally recognized fundamental place of reading in education, intellectual development and enrichment, and literacy, discouraging children from reading, let alone associating it with punishment by denying or even adding reading time as a punitive measure, is not a good direction to go in. She reluctantly acknowledged she was wrong but easily apologized and I asked that she direct her acknowledgement and apology to my son not me. Which she did. Fortunately he only has today and tomorrow then he's done with them for this summer. Next summer, we are considering that he may be able to stay home by himself at least part of the time.
Last edited: