New forum member brand (Rugged West)

[TartuWolf]

I didn't mean to imply it's a bad jacket or that these are deal breakers considering the price point.
Like I mentioned, I agree adding the zippers doesn't do a thing and seems unnecessary - guess the way I phrased it didn't make it clear.

All good, I'm pretty sure everyone on TFL wishes Leilah and her business all the best We analyse, discuss, identify problematic areas, suggest improvements.

 

[bigmanbigtruck]

All good, I'm pretty sure everyone on TFL wishes Leilah and her business all the best

The more the merrier!

 

[MrProper]

I'm not sure if I've missed something, but wasn't it common practice here at TFL at some point to only discuss the fit of a jacket if this was requested as part of a fit check, for example?
I don't think it's nice when someone proudly presents their jacket and is obviously happy with it and then goes on to tell them all the things that don't fit on their new jacket.
I don't want to rule out the possibility that I haven't given my opinion without being asked, but I try not to.

 

[bigmanbigtruck]

I'm not sure if I've missed something, but wasn't it common practice here at TFL at some point to only discuss the fit of a jacket if this was requested as part of a fit check, for example?
I don't think it's nice when someone proudly presents their jacket and is obviously happy with it and then goes on to tell them all the things that don't fit on their new jacket.
I don't want to rule out the possibility that I haven't given my opinion without being asked, but I try not to.

That's a fair point - but I feel like the comments were directed more at the maker and their design rather than how the jacket fit the person.

Tbh, I think the fit on the jacket is just fine and do hope that person continues to enjoy it.
It's just the other small details we got hung up on.

 

[herculance]

Got my Sentinel in black tea core.
View attachment 701164 View attachment 701165 View attachment 701166 View attachment 701167 View attachment 701168

Looks great on you! Love the shine too esp with a dressier outfit.

 

[Leilah Wilde]

Hey members,

I actually really appreciate the scrutiny some of my designs have received here - it’s genuinely helpful. I’d be a moron to get defensive over people pointing out things that can help me improve.

I’m in the midst of reworking some of my patterns. I want to move away from anything that feels too much like a “fashion jacket” (each time that has been mentioned before I find myself shuddering ) and steer more into proper vintage repro territory. We did a test run for a new pattern using some really beautiful Tuscan steerhide and it turned out brilliantly. I’ll upload some pics here today.

Cuff circumference is definitely one of those tricky areas. I definitely agree that they need to be narrowed, but the question is by how much - I don’t want to make them uncomfortably tight. For example, my HD Cycle Queen has super snug cuffs - even on my tiny wrists, I can’t zip them down all the way, and the little opening it leaves at the bottom really irks me. That’s definitely something I want to avoid.

Also, big thank you to those who have posted pictures here. I’m always so happy (and proud) to share the thread with friends and family. Your support and feedback really mean a lot.

 

[NielsLyhne]

Can’t wait to see the new pattern @Leilah Wilde

 

[P2D]

Hey members,

I actually really appreciate the scrutiny some of my designs have received here - it’s genuinely helpful. I’d be a moron to get defensive over people pointing out things that can help me improve.

I’m in the midst of reworking some of my patterns. I want to move away from anything that feels too much like a “fashion jacket” (each time that has been mentioned before I find myself shuddering ) and steer more into proper vintage repro territory. We did a test run for a new pattern using some really beautiful Tuscan steerhide and it turned out brilliantly. I’ll upload some pics here today.

Cuff circumference is definitely one of those tricky areas. I definitely agree that they need to be narrowed, but the question is by how much - I don’t want to make them uncomfortably tight. For example, my HD Cycle Queen has super snug cuffs - even on my tiny wrists, I can’t zip them down all the way, and the little opening it leaves at the bottom really irks me. That’s definitely something I want to avoid.

Also, big thank you to those who have posted pictures here. I’m always so happy (and proud) to share the thread with friends and family. Your support and feedback really mean a lot.

This level of humility is really impressive and appreciated