Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Hats Plus in Chicago: trip report

ScottyBlues

Familiar Face
Messages
83
Location
Chapel Hill, NC
I went on vacation last week to visit my parents in Michigan. Typically, we fly into Chicago and drive the rest of the way. This time, I wanted to stop into a hat store, since there aren't any in my area. I chose Hats Plus from their website (http://www.hats-plus.com/), looking for a large selection in many brands.

Hats Plus is fairly large, with two main sections. The one section has a lot of hats that are more geared for the average person rather than the hat aficionado. The other section has several glass cases with the good stuff, as well as some of the lower-end brands on racks.

The top brands include Borsalino, Stetson, Biltmore, Guerra, Dobbs, and Christy's. Of these, I was most interested in checking out the Biltmore hats, based on some of the posts I read on this forum. Indeed, the Eleganza line impressed me as the best hats in the store. The felt is very soft and pliable, and the finishing is top-notch. I bought a Rosselini in Black Olive, which is a great color! It's a center-dent and comes with the wind string. This is probably the best production hat I've seen, barring the 100% beaver offerings from some companies.

I tried on a lot of hats and was amazed at the variation in the sizes, even within the same manufacturer. I typically wear a 7 3/8, but I tried on some Stetsons in 7 1/4 that were WAY too large. The sizing was more consistent from Biltmore, but I wound up buying a 7 1/4 because it fit best. If I had ordered over the internet I would have ordered the 7 3/8, which would have been too big. Yes, you can send it back, but there's the hassle and the expense.

Nothing replaces the ability to walk into the store an try on dozens and dozens of hats. You can really see the color and how well the shape and brim work with your face. I recently bought a vintage pork pie by Bond, which looks great on me, but every traditional pork pie I tried on in the store looked silly. I think it's because the Bond has a much higher crown than normal.

I also bought a couple of Stetsons. They're the lower grade Royal Stetsons, but they're great for every day wear. One is a model called the Bangor, which is a pork pie, but it's a C-crown with a pinch. It's a very unusual profile that looks more like a traditional fedora from the side but with the very nice pork pie crown! I'll post pictures later when I have a chance.

The final hat I bought is a Stetson Grenadier. It's a C-crown with a thin, bound edge. It has the same kind of sweat band that is common with the western hats, which is a softer, suede-like band rather than the smooth, black band that is typical in the Royal Stetsons. It's not the best hat I own, but I like the color and it's good for when I don't want to worry too much about my hat.

I was thinking about buying a staw hat. They did have a pretty good selection, but I was out of time and had exhausted the hat budget for a while. The people were very helpful. I highly recommend them to anyone in or visiting Chicago.
 

David Conwill

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,854
Location
Bennington, VT 05201
I don't suppose you got up here to check out "The Hat Collection" in Muskegon Heights, did you? I still haven't been there myself, but I've got a two-week break coming, so who knows!

-Dave
 

ScottyBlues

Familiar Face
Messages
83
Location
Chapel Hill, NC
No visit to Muskegon Heights

I was sick the whole week, so I didn't get to do as much as I wanted. Besides, after visiting Hats Plus, I had exhausted my hat budget.
 

carldelo

One Too Many
Messages
1,568
Location
Astoria, NYC
Nice review

Thanks for the review. I agree about visiting vs. internet. I went by Bencraft Hats in Brooklyn this weekend. Within 5 minutes I had tried on and ruled out half a dozen hats I'd been drooling at online for months - they just didn't look right on me (they were the Eleganza, Stetson Windham, Borsalino Alessandria among others). Strangely, a derby looked pretty good. I wound up buying a Stetson Ashland in Cordova that the clerk suggested - as my wife said, 'that hat looks like it was made for you'. It took the visit to realize that a 2-1/4" brim is a good look for me in addition to a low crown. I just checked out the Bangor that you mentioned, which looks odd but cool. No luck finding a picture of the Grenadier - I'd love to see pictures of both when you can manage it.
Cheers, Carl
 

Bob Roberts

I'll Lock Up
Messages
11,201
Location
milford ct
I went on vacation last week to visit my parents in Michigan. Typically, we fly into Chicago and drive the rest of the way. This time, I wanted to stop into a hat store, since there aren't any in my area. I chose Hats Plus from their website (http://www.hats-plus.com/), looking for a large selection in many brands.

Hats Plus is fairly large, with two main sections. The one section has a lot of hats that are more geared for the average person rather than the hat aficionado. The other section has several glass cases with the good stuff, as well as some of the lower-end brands on racks.

The top brands include Borsalino, Stetson, Biltmore, Guerra, Dobbs, and Christy's. Of these, I was most interested in checking out the Biltmore hats, based on some of the posts I read on this forum. Indeed, the Eleganza line impressed me as the best hats in the store. The felt is very soft and pliable, and the finishing is top-notch. I bought a Rosselini in Black Olive, which is a great color! It's a center-dent and comes with the wind string. This is probably the best production hat I've seen, barring the 100% beaver offerings from some companies.

I tried on a lot of hats and was amazed at the variation in the sizes, even within the same manufacturer. I typically wear a 7 3/8, but I tried on some Stetsons in 7 1/4 that were WAY too large. The sizing was more consistent from Biltmore, but I wound up buying a 7 1/4 because it fit best. If I had ordered over the internet I would have ordered the 7 3/8, which would have been too big. Yes, you can send it back, but there's the hassle and the expense.

Nothing replaces the ability to walk into the store an try on dozens and dozens of hats. You can really see the color and how well the shape and brim work with your face. I recently bought a vintage pork pie by Bond, which looks great on me, but every traditional pork pie I tried on in the store looked silly. I think it's because the Bond has a much higher crown than normal.

I also bought a couple of Stetsons. They're the lower grade Royal Stetsons, but they're great for every day wear. One is a model called the Bangor, which is a pork pie, but it's a C-crown with a pinch. It's a very unusual profile that looks more like a traditional fedora from the side but with the very nice pork pie crown! I'll post pictures later when I have a chance.

The final hat I bought is a Stetson Grenadier. It's a C-crown with a thin, bound edge. It has the same kind of sweat band that is common with the western hats, which is a softer, suede-like band rather than the smooth, black band that is typical in the Royal Stetsons. It's not the best hat I own, but I like the color and it's good for when I don't want to worry too much about my hat.

I was thinking about buying a staw hat. They did have a pretty good selection, but I was out of time and had exhausted the hat budget for a while. The people were very helpful. I highly recommend them to anyone in or visiting Chicago.
I have bought 3 hats on line and over the phone from Hats Plus. Two NOS Canadian Biltmores and one Guerra Brand. The Biltmores were the Rosselini and the Eleganza. Great hats and good people. Recommend them highly.
 

addison

One of the Regulars
Messages
164
Location
Wisconsin
Thanks for the review!
You know, now that you mention it I have the same experience with Stetson...they are BIG!
I'm the same hat size as you, and the last Stetson I tried on was a 7 1/4 that fit too big on me, and I've had similar experiences before with Stetson.
 

LabRat 101

New in Town
Messages
28
Location
Brookfield, IL
Thanks for the review, I live in the west suburbs of Chicago and have been to Hats Plus. Great staff, large selection. I bought a Stetson Pinnacle, they had my size in all the colors. Just nice to walk into a place and have options. Glad you had a good experience.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,160
Messages
3,075,412
Members
54,124
Latest member
usedxPielt
Top