Oversized? not even close imo, I would even say you could go up a size and it would still look great(like the A2 leather jacket I do think this military style looks best when not super slimmed).
I have the exact same pea coat that I ordered directly from Japan (Rodeo Japan Pine Avenue). Buzz Rickson make two versions; the short (hip length) coat and this one (above knee length). I'm 6'1 (186 cm) tall and feel that the shorter version, while traditional, looks a bit awkward/unbalanced compared to the longer length. Plus, this version has two extra corduroy-lined side pockets and a nicer 100% wool flannel lining.
Thanks for the thorough answer!
This coat is an excellent alternative to your shorter, slimmer leather jackets. The pea coat is a paragon of masculine style and just looks so weighty and substantial. Completely different vibe from leather.Thanks for the thorough answer!
I'm glad I went for this longer version (BR14146), couldn't be happier with the product as a whole. The extra hand warmer pockets and the wool lining really elevates it above any other pea coats I've seen and I like the longer length as well.
I also feel that it looks better when buttoned up, but I rather love the collar up look as long as it's not fully buttoned up. When button up and collar up then yeah, full turtle mode haha.
I'm much more used to lean and short jackets (focusing on leather ones of course) therefore the roomy coat is hard to swallow. The extra room does make it extremely future proof compared to all of my other jackets - I could still wear it in 20-30 years even if I gain 10-20 kg along the way.
My narrow understanding of a good fit and innability to correlate this with a peacoat tank:
What Jacket Are You Wearing Today?
Since I bought my first Y’2 leather jacket last fall, I was lucky enought to find two other Y'2 jackets in my size on the second hand market. I just received this one on eBay. It’s the same size as my other Y’2 jackets but fits a bit tighter. But since Valentine's Day dinner with my wife, I've...www.thefedoralounge.com
So, here's another interesting aquisition.
Fit seems so-so for me. If it were me, I'd try to get rid of some of the wrinkles by gently steaming the coat and also flattening the lapel.
c
Looks good.
The back length adjustment turned out perfect, Fiesar. All around the length looks like excellent tailoring. And you were spot-on with the contrast stitching being highlighted with a multi-panel back. Turns out envy shows up in shades other than green!The back-length was also shortened to 25,5 Inch despite me being 6'7, as I have a short torso and I prefer vintage-y jackets to hit roughly at belt level.
The back is modified into a multi panel design to get more out of the cream contrast stitching
I have to say I really quite happy with how it turned out even if it's not perfect - my natural waist is very slim and the Aero halfbelts are still rather boxy by design, even the Premier. Personally, I don't think I could consciously improve the fit that much even if I had the chance for a remake.
John Lofgren Monkey Boots Shinki Horsebuttt - $1,136 The classic monkey boot silhouette in an incredibly rich Shinki russet horse leather. 
Grant Stone Diesel Boot Dark Olive Chromexcel - $395 Goodyear welted, Horween Chromexcel, classic good looks. 
Schott 568 Vandals Jacket - $1,250 The classic Perfecto motorcycle jacket, in a very special limited-edition Schott double rider style. It billows across the back and buckles at the neck with only the tee shirt. You could probably go down a size. With a bulky layer it should have decent maneuverability. An extra layer will also raise the hem. Looks like it will be a versatile item for your wardrobe.
Solid fit. It is not the super hero super shaped cut, but it looks comfortable, well within fit range without being too big. A size down may look smarter on pictures, but I bet you it wouldn't feel comfortable and how it feels is much more important than how it looks.
Yes, going with 42L next
