Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

What Hat Are You Wearing Today ?

bmw1976

One of the Regulars
Messages
117
Location
Boise, ID
Portis stingy from the late 1940's or early 50's, but I havent researched Portis history yet. I believe it used to have an oilskin liner that disintegrated. Silver Beaver 3X blend. I dig the hat box.
20260210_153631.jpg
20260210_153830.jpg
20260210_153852.jpg
20260210_154327.jpg
20260210_154006.jpg
 
Messages
2
Cool. However, I'm unclear - is this vintage from the Ming Dynasty or a reproduction?

Either way, way to mix it up.
It’s reproduction, haha. You’re absolutely right to ask that. There’s an interesting piece of history behind this.

Genuine vintage clothing from the Ming Dynasty is extremely rare. One reason is that it dates back more than 400 years. The other reason is a major historical event in Chinese history: the Qing Dynasty — the last feudal imperial dynasty in China — was founded by the Manchu people.

The Manchus were a nomadic and hunting ethnic group. To maintain stable rule, they ordered Han Chinese people to shave their heads and change their clothing. The Manchu hairstyle required a braid less than one centimeter thick; all other hair had to be shaved off (similar to the hairstyle of the Cossacks in Eastern Europe).

By contrast, traditional Han people never shaved any hair. They kept it long and tied it up on top of their heads. In ancient China, people believed that the body, skin, and hair were gifts from one’s parents, so they had to be cherished and not easily damaged. Hair was seen as something dignified and meaningful.

When the Manchu order was issued, it triggered resistance among nearly all Han people. But the Manchus enforced a brutal rule: if you wanted to keep your hair, you would lose your head; if you wanted to keep your head, you had to give up your hair. Millions of people were killed for refusing to change their hairstyle or wear Manchu clothing.

In the end, the resistance was suppressed, and most pre‑Qing clothing was destroyed. That’s why almost no genuine vintage Ming Dynasty clothing survives today.

However, there are countless portraits and unearthed artifacts from the Ming Dynasty. Modern reproductions are mainly based on these portraits and relics.

Photos 1 and 2 show traditional Han hairstyles.

Photo 3 is a Terracotta Warrior from the Qin Dynasty, dating back 2,246 years ago.

Photos 3 and 4 show Ming Dynasty gentlemen and soldiers wearing damao(traditional Ming hats).

Photos 5 and 6 show Qing Dynasty officials and merchants who were forced to wear Manchu clothing and wear Manchu-style braids.
54aea5e2c1854b52b050d7142aff9a51.png
cfa9d97ddd9a4ab4bfdd9bc5ad1bef09.png
f8fa3a69e349402e899bbc7aa03bab0d.png
b275cec3d139415ea995165a37487057.png
0a417097ff68460b8d2217a1d9601fc7.png
97b5e9cc5e0448bb9517133e9731922a.png
8f64050566af48aaa99f532a0043fc1d.png
 

jeffgarf

One Too Many
Messages
1,169
Location
Jerusalem, Israel
A late 80's (I believe) Borsalino in gray for today. I say late 80's because the hat band already had the logo on it, but the liner and the size tag are unusual in my experience for 1990's and later hats. With the size tag, I might have assumed it was US made, but it does specifically say "Made in Italy" unlike the 90's Bollman licensed hats. Interesting. I should also point out that the felt is definitely Borsalino.

PXL_20260211_130908248.jpg PXL_20260211_130913262.jpg PXL_20260211_130931223.jpg PXL_20260211_133420181.jpg
 

RickP

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,822
To my kid brain this is one of my all time favorite combos today...hadnt had it out in quite some time. Really smooth 3x stetson long oval in fern green felt with rose colored ribbon and binding. It just floats perfectly into place up top.

1000005051.jpg
1000005050.jpg
1000005052.jpg
1000005053.jpg
1000005054.jpg
 

jeffgarf

One Too Many
Messages
1,169
Location
Jerusalem, Israel
A late 80's (I believe) Borsalino in gray for today. I say late 80's because the hat band already had the logo on it, but the liner and the size tag are unusual in my experience for 1990's and later hats. With the size tag, I might have assumed it was US made, but it does specifically say "Made in Italy" unlike the 90's Bollman licensed hats. Interesting. I should also point out that the felt is definitely Borsalino.

View attachment 768878 View attachment 768879 View attachment 768880 View attachment 768881
An update, with help from @besdor. It has been determined that this hat is from the first years of the Spinetta Marengo factory, where Borsalino relocated from its original Alessandria factory in the late 80's.
 
Messages
19,987
Location
Funkytown, USA
It’s reproduction, haha. You’re absolutely right to ask that. There’s an interesting piece of history behind this.

Genuine vintage clothing from the Ming Dynasty is extremely rare. One reason is that it dates back more than 400 years. The other reason is a major historical event in Chinese history: the Qing Dynasty — the last feudal imperial dynasty in China — was founded by the Manchu people.

The Manchus were a nomadic and hunting ethnic group. To maintain stable rule, they ordered Han Chinese people to shave their heads and change their clothing. The Manchu hairstyle required a braid less than one centimeter thick; all other hair had to be shaved off (similar to the hairstyle of the Cossacks in Eastern Europe).

By contrast, traditional Han people never shaved any hair. They kept it long and tied it up on top of their heads. In ancient China, people believed that the body, skin, and hair were gifts from one’s parents, so they had to be cherished and not easily damaged. Hair was seen as something dignified and meaningful.

When the Manchu order was issued, it triggered resistance among nearly all Han people. But the Manchus enforced a brutal rule: if you wanted to keep your hair, you would lose your head; if you wanted to keep your head, you had to give up your hair. Millions of people were killed for refusing to change their hairstyle or wear Manchu clothing.

In the end, the resistance was suppressed, and most pre‑Qing clothing was destroyed. That’s why almost no genuine vintage Ming Dynasty clothing survives today.

However, there are countless portraits and unearthed artifacts from the Ming Dynasty. Modern reproductions are mainly based on these portraits and relics.

Photos 1 and 2 show traditional Han hairstyles.

Photo 3 is a Terracotta Warrior from the Qin Dynasty, dating back 2,246 years ago.

Photos 3 and 4 show Ming Dynasty gentlemen and soldiers wearing damao(traditional Ming hats).

Photos 5 and 6 show Qing Dynasty officials and merchants who were forced to wear Manchu clothing and wear Manchu-style braids. View attachment 768844 View attachment 768845 View attachment 768846 View attachment 768847 View attachment 768848 View attachment 768849 View attachment 768850

I figured it was a repro, but had to ask. Thanks for the history lesson, as well.
 

VoodooSan

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,316
Location
Boise, ID
It’s reproduction, haha. You’re absolutely right to ask that. There’s an interesting piece of history behind this.

Genuine vintage clothing from the Ming Dynasty is extremely rare. One reason is that it dates back more than 400 years. The other reason is a major historical event in Chinese history: the Qing Dynasty — the last feudal imperial dynasty in China — was founded by the Manchu people.

The Manchus were a nomadic and hunting ethnic group. To maintain stable rule, they ordered Han Chinese people to shave their heads and change their clothing. The Manchu hairstyle required a braid less than one centimeter thick; all other hair had to be shaved off (similar to the hairstyle of the Cossacks in Eastern Europe).

By contrast, traditional Han people never shaved any hair. They kept it long and tied it up on top of their heads. In ancient China, people believed that the body, skin, and hair were gifts from one’s parents, so they had to be cherished and not easily damaged. Hair was seen as something dignified and meaningful.

When the Manchu order was issued, it triggered resistance among nearly all Han people. But the Manchus enforced a brutal rule: if you wanted to keep your hair, you would lose your head; if you wanted to keep your head, you had to give up your hair. Millions of people were killed for refusing to change their hairstyle or wear Manchu clothing.

In the end, the resistance was suppressed, and most pre‑Qing clothing was destroyed. That’s why almost no genuine vintage Ming Dynasty clothing survives today.

However, there are countless portraits and unearthed artifacts from the Ming Dynasty. Modern reproductions are mainly based on these portraits and relics.

Photos 1 and 2 show traditional Han hairstyles.

Photo 3 is a Terracotta Warrior from the Qin Dynasty, dating back 2,246 years ago.

Photos 3 and 4 show Ming Dynasty gentlemen and soldiers wearing damao(traditional Ming hats).

Photos 5 and 6 show Qing Dynasty officials and merchants who were forced to wear Manchu clothing and wear Manchu-style braids. View attachment 768844 View attachment 768845 View attachment 768846 View attachment 768847 View attachment 768848 View attachment 768849 View attachment 768850
Fascinating history, thanks for sharing.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
114,485
Messages
3,175,515
Members
58,331
Latest member
thedickybow
Top