- Messages
- 17,190
- Location
- New York City
Having been raised by a professional gambler (and, to be honest, bookie), gambling was always a business to me. That said, my dad had noting - nor do I have anything - against a $5 or $10 bet for rooting interest or the occasional lottery ticket for fun, as long as one is clear that gambling is a business and a "fun" wager is entertainment (like going to the movies).
From that silly early kickstart on money, math, odds and skill (I was at racetracks by the time I was seven - both my father and grandmother took me - she was a gambler too) - I landed up on Wall Street in a trading seat and really, truly and deeply learned about the business of odds, betting, future outcomes, emotions, luck, skill, strategy and everything else that goes into successful gambling.
And, yes, one can be a successful gambler, but it is a very hard job. While many on Wall Street also love casino gambling, Wall Street indirectly taught me to hate casino gambling. I have no interest in betting in a construct that takes +/- 18 cents of every dollar out for the house and then sets the rules of the game so that the odds ensure the house wins. If anyone doubts the later (the former is hard fact; although, the exact amount of the take might be a bit different today), remember that "card counting" was made "illegal" because it was a very fair way that the house could lose.
Gambling addicts, like all addicts, deserve our sympathy, but they are not approaching Wall Street or casinos as a business or as entertainment - it's sadly just an enameler of their addiction. Gambling as a serious business is best, IMHO, played either against others - like in poker - when there is no house take or on financial markets where the house take and vigorish is very, very low (honestly, if you learn the ins and outs, it is silly low, even for the retail investor, on Wall Street - and only lower since the transparency of the internet).
I make my living doing this and have my entire professional career - it's a hard business, but what isn't? I also, as noted, have no negative view of betting as entertainment. The key is not making a category error; i.e., know when you are gambling as a business (then, make sure you've done your homework) versus as entertainment (then expect to lose everything - you might not - set your limit ahead of time and have fun).
To the last point, you can go to a Broadway show and dinner for, easily, $300 a person in this over-priced city or go out to the race track, make $5 and $10 wagers on each race, lose everyone, and still not spend $300. For my entertainment dollar - you can't give me a theater ticket for free (I can't stand going to the theater), but a nice weather day out at Belmont a few times a year is heaven.
From that silly early kickstart on money, math, odds and skill (I was at racetracks by the time I was seven - both my father and grandmother took me - she was a gambler too) - I landed up on Wall Street in a trading seat and really, truly and deeply learned about the business of odds, betting, future outcomes, emotions, luck, skill, strategy and everything else that goes into successful gambling.
And, yes, one can be a successful gambler, but it is a very hard job. While many on Wall Street also love casino gambling, Wall Street indirectly taught me to hate casino gambling. I have no interest in betting in a construct that takes +/- 18 cents of every dollar out for the house and then sets the rules of the game so that the odds ensure the house wins. If anyone doubts the later (the former is hard fact; although, the exact amount of the take might be a bit different today), remember that "card counting" was made "illegal" because it was a very fair way that the house could lose.
Gambling addicts, like all addicts, deserve our sympathy, but they are not approaching Wall Street or casinos as a business or as entertainment - it's sadly just an enameler of their addiction. Gambling as a serious business is best, IMHO, played either against others - like in poker - when there is no house take or on financial markets where the house take and vigorish is very, very low (honestly, if you learn the ins and outs, it is silly low, even for the retail investor, on Wall Street - and only lower since the transparency of the internet).
I make my living doing this and have my entire professional career - it's a hard business, but what isn't? I also, as noted, have no negative view of betting as entertainment. The key is not making a category error; i.e., know when you are gambling as a business (then, make sure you've done your homework) versus as entertainment (then expect to lose everything - you might not - set your limit ahead of time and have fun).
To the last point, you can go to a Broadway show and dinner for, easily, $300 a person in this over-priced city or go out to the race track, make $5 and $10 wagers on each race, lose everyone, and still not spend $300. For my entertainment dollar - you can't give me a theater ticket for free (I can't stand going to the theater), but a nice weather day out at Belmont a few times a year is heaven.