- Messages
- 18,453
- Location
- New York City
Burn, Witch, Burn (AKA Night of the Eagle) from 1962 with Peter Wyngarde and Janet Blair
"The Rational Mind Versus Witchcraft" could have been a third title for Burn, Witch, Burn, also known as Night of the Eagle, a classic horror tale. Set in a small college in England where, as the cliché goes, the faculty politics are particularly ferocious because the stakes are so low.
Peter Wyngarde plays a young, star psychology professor – considered brilliant, also popular with his students – who with his wife, played by Janet Blair, lives in a beautiful college-provided gothic house. Life is going well for him as he's even up for promotion to department head.
Things seem a bit off with Blair, though, as he discovers she's practicing some sort of witchcraft, which she claims is protecting them from the "evil trying to hurt them." He, being an Aristotelian rationalist, dismisses her "hobby" as nonsense, until he sees how much it affects her.
The structure of the picture follows those two threads: one is his life at college, where there's plenty of jealousy, and the other is his life at home, where he keeps trying to get his wife off witchcraft, a witchcraft she insists they need.
In fairness to Blair, after Wyngarde gets rid of all her witchy paraphernalia – it's a creepy scene when he burns it all in the fireplace, but a presumed dead spider crawls out alive – things start to go a bit wonky at work for him, but who doesn't have ups and downs in his or her career?
Wyngarde is falsely accused of forcing himself on a female student (treated as a serious crime, hence another example of the past being less one sided than is often argued today). While his academic position starts to wobble, Blair drifts further away into her witchcraft world.
Eventually, things come to a head in a long Act III where Wyngarde, in desperation, tries to use witchcraft himself to save his wife from drowning, all while another source of witchcraft at the college is partially exposed in a fiery conclusion.
What the above high-level plot summary fails to capture is the haunting atmosphere of this horror-in-a-normal-place story. It is, though, a normal place populated with Gothic buildings dating back hundreds of years. Plus, it's England, so it's almost always drearily fog-shrouded.
Gargoyles, deep archways, foot-thick stone walls, huge wooden doors, and – at Wyngarde and Blair's getaway cabin – a cliff to the ocean and an underground vault full of sarcophaguses where, as noted, Wyngarde tries, in desperation and for the first time, to use black magic.
It's the old "there are no atheists in foxholes" aphorism come to life as Wyngarde – the disbeliever who mocks witchcraft and the supernatural – attempts to save his "possessed" wife from drowning.
It's also an outstanding scene in the dark woods at night: a storm whipping, a room of buried tombs discovered, and a man throwing logic and reason out the window as he plays with old pictures, matches, and herbs to try to summon otherworldly forces to rescue Blair.
Believing is no longer his issue, it's how to use the dark arts to get his life back in order. Blair's problem is a bit different as she's always believed, but her husband burned most of the tools of her craft.
Wyngarde is a good choice here as he looks normal, but there is also something off about him – something just not quite aligned with the boy-genius academic he plays. Think of him like an English version of Anthony Perkins from this era.
Equally well cast is Blair, who flips from regular professor's wife to demonic force with frightening ease. With the wonderful first name in this one of Tansy, she's a much more believable domesticated version of a witch than the silly versions on 1960s American TV.
There are several good surprises waiting in the climax that you'll want to see fresh, but nothing that, for regular horror fans, hasn't been riffed on since. Still, it's an engaging climax for the genre.
That is the entire crux of the movie – Burn, Witch, Burn is an excellent low-budget black-and-white horror film (something the Brits did in their sleep in this era). It's a potent mix of rationalism, dreams, beliefs, sorcery, evil, desire, and jealousy.
If you don't like the genre, pass, but if horror is up your alley and you haven't seen this one, it's a fun find – well, an eerily haunting one – that you'll probably be surprised you hadn't seen before.


