- Messages
- 18,301
- Location
- New York City
In This Our Life from 1942 with Bette Davis, Olivia de Havilland, Charles Coburn, George Brent, Ernest Anderson, Frank Craven, Dennis Morgan, and Hattie McDaniel
Warner Bros. churned out several of these A-picture southern-family melodramas in this era, with In This Our Life being, perhaps, the most melodramatic of them all. Naturally, it starred the queen of the Warner's lot, Bette Davis.
Warner Bros. also included other big names – Olivia de Havilland, Charles Coburn, Dennis Morgan, and George Brent – had John Huston direct, and then just let the story rip. Yet it also layered in a very forward-looking civil rights message – wonderfully – right out in the open.
Bette Davis plays the spoiled daughter of a no-longer-rich father, played by Frank Craven. She's also the niece of the man who ruined her father – played by Charles Coburn – who spoils her, Davis, rotten (those are carefully chosen words).
At the movie's opening, Davis jilts her fiancé, played by George Brent, at the altar and then runs off with her sister’s husband. De Havilland plays Davis' sister; Morgan plays the husband who leaves de Havilland for Davis.
Selfish Davis then drives Morgan to drink and *******, which leads to her returning home to take another run at Brent – now married to de Havilland. For those keeping score, Davis is now trying to steal another of her sister's husbands.
All this is awful enough, but it gets worse when Davis, angry at being stood up by Brent – who isn't falling for her like she expected – drives her car in a blind rage and hits a mother and daughter. The daughter is killed; the mother is badly injured, and Davis flees the scene.
There's more, though, as Davis then sets up a young black man, played by Ernest Anderson, to take the fall for her crime. Anderson had worked for Davis' family, but is now working for Brent, a lawyer, because he, Anderson, is studying to become a lawyer himself.
Davis is unbelievably ruthless in trying to blame Anderson, but de Havilland and Brent stand by him. For 1942, this is an amazing pro-civil-rights story that isn't "slipped in" as they often were, but is right out in the open forcing you to see how brutally unfair it all was.
Davis, as the force-of-nature bad sister, and de Havilland, as the sweet and kind one, are wonderful antagonists – just as Coburn, playing the ruthless businessman, and Craven, playing the kind but weak man, mirror the sisters.
These are acting professionals who can take good, not great material and, under Huston's smart directing, make the movie seem better than it is.
A note must also be made of Anderson's moving performance as a young black man trying to become a lawyer. When "the system" turns against him, his apathetic despair is heartbreaking, demonstrating how beaten down his race rightfully felt at this time – especially in the South.
In This Our Life is fun melodrama as you get to hate the bad guys, Davis and Colburn, and root for the good ones, de Havilland, Brent, Craven and Anderson. It would be nothing more than high-gloss fluff, though, if not for its ahead-of-its-time civil-rights statement.
N.B. Look for an early scene where talented Hattie McDaniel, playing the family's maid, without any rancor, absolutely destroys lovely Olivia de Havilland with a matter-of-fact one-word comment about de Havilland's looks. The comment is hilarious – it leaves de Havilland dumbstruck as McDaniel blithely walks away. See the scene here: https://www.google.com/search?clien...#fpstate=ive&vld=cid:597e40a4,vid:NVN05kYaujw


