Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

What Are You Reading

Harp

I'll Lock Up
Messages
9,344
Location
Chicago, IL US
^ Reading that Knox link rendered hard verdict my capricious college years. A man has to
follow his own star, and an individual who has fixed inner sight upon the heavens for clear
understanding of himself finds purpose denied most men.

...I can recall standing at the Honolulu Art Museum Beretania & Ward corner about
two o'clock in the afternoon. The sun, breeze, and utter magnificence mixed the splendor
of youthful insouciance. :cool:
 

Tiki Tom

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,105
Location
Oahu, North Polynesia
I just finished reading “Frankenstein” by Mary Shelley, published in 1818 (275 pages).
As noted above, I’ve been avoiding Frankenstein for years. How can a book about a flat-headed monster with bolts in his neck be a classic?
But finally, I’d heard one too many book nerd tell me that it is more than a classic… Frankenstein is a foundational myth of the western world; it is the first example of the science fiction genre; the book is both gothic and romantic, and is loaded with deep psychological and sociological insights. Blah, blah, blah! But, okay, since it was October, I would read Frankenstein.

To my surprise, it really is very good. First, it’s nothing like the movie. Despite being 200 years old, the language is pretty easy to read. Frankenstein is more of a psychological thriller than a horror story. It does pit science (which was just coming into its own) against romantic notions like beauty and nature and the love of family. The book has a nice story arc that follows our ideas of beginning, middle, and end. The best part of the book, IMHO, is when it spends a couple of chapters telling the tale from the monster’s point of view. Oh, the humanity! I’ll bet that most readers can recall a period in their lives when they felt just like that monster. We also watch as doctor Victor Frankenstein slowly becomes more and more like his monster; cut off from society and captured by deep, ugly emotions. And there is more to it than that; as when the monster discovers the inner workings of humans and society. It is probably not stretching it too far to say that Mary Shelley was ahead of her time. And certain aspects of the story still resonate today.

As I said, it is a good read. If you are just embarking on reading the classics, you could do worse than starting with Frankenstein. It is fairly short and is divided up into quick chapters. It’s amazing that Mary Shelley wrote it when she was just 19. There’s a lot of backstory that gives the book additional weight: Mary Shelley grew up without a mother, and it’s noteworthy that the monster rages at being abandoned by its parent.

On the down side, Frankenstein does get off to a fairly slow start. The monster is only created around page 50. And for my tastes, Dr Frankenstein spends too much time whining about how miserable he is. But these are fairly small quibbles.

All that aside, human hubris being what it is, after reading Frankenstein, I now feel smugly “in the know” whenever an allusion to Frankenstein comes up. (For starters, I always thought that Dr Frankenstein was German. He is not. He is Swiss). Kinda fun, and well worth reading.
 
Last edited:

Tiki Tom

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,105
Location
Oahu, North Polynesia
^ Reading that Knox link rendered hard verdict my capricious college years. A man has to
follow his own star, and an individual who has fixed inner sight upon the heavens for clear
understanding of himself finds purpose denied most men.

^^^^^ very good comment. I hope you will enjoy the following additional article on Knox. The last third of the article ties together, and makes sense of, Knox’s battle field experience and his love for the Greek Classics. (I also didn’t realize how highly decorated Knox was. And that was just for the Second World War!)

https://newrepublic.com/article/77450/the-warrior-humanist-bernard-knox

WHY am I STILL going on about Bernard Knox??? Is it a weird fixation?

Because now I’m working my way through “The Norton Book of Classical Literature” that I got from the library. Knox’s introduction and commentary of each piece is succinct and thoughtful. And although Knox never mentions his own wartime experiences, I think I can hear feint echos of it as he introduces Homer and the ILiad. Anyway, I’m enjoying the book. It’s a great way to reintroduce myself with the Greek and Roman classics. Im kind of cherry picking my way through it, as it is a whopping 866 pages long! It ends with Saint Augustine discussing his sinful ways and his painful conversion to Christianity. I needed to read that!
 
Last edited:
Messages
18,526
Location
New York City
images-3.jpeg

One Fine Day by Mollie Panter-Downes, published in 1947


Sic transit gloria mundi.


The British Empire did not end in a day. It was a long slog of decades, starting perhaps with WWI and ending perhaps with WWII or the Suez crisis in 1956 – or maybe it just faded slowly over the ensuing decades. Its average citizens had to adjust in real time too.

In One Fine Day, author Mollie Panter-Downes draws an oblique but poignant portrait of one middle-class family adjusting to, or maybe stumbling through the austerity and social changes of postwar England.

Panter-Downes smartly confines the story to a single ordinary summer day in 1946. It’s the family’s mundane actions – queueing early for food, commuting to London for work – and inner thoughts – Laura is so tired now, Stephen is so frustrated with the garden – that reveal their world.

It's a postwar world that has fallen short of the prewar one for this representative middle-class couple who can't recapture their old lifestyle in large part because of rationing and a lack of domestic help: the war accelerated a shift away from domestic service and to factory and office work for young women.

Laura now has just one woman who comes in to help several days a week. The woman is fully aware of her value as one of the village’s few domestics. Before the war, the family had several servants and at least one full- or nearly full-time gardener. Now there’s more work for the family, and less gets done.

Laura is a mediocre cook, a mediocre housekeeper, a mediocre shopper (getting food in the postwar shortages takes skills that Laura doesn't have), and a mediocre parent to her young daughter, Victoria. She tries and means well, but not everyone is cut out to be a homemaker.

Especially when one wasn't trained for it. That might be the biggest rub: this is all new to the family. Laura grew up on an estate and was stepping down in class when she married Stephen before the war, but now she's in a world she hardly knew existed.

Panter-Downes captures so much through Laura’s thoughts as she stands in line at the tea shop. Laura is placid on the outside, but she can see how much the shopkeeper enjoys bossing her customers around: “Only six cakes each.” The Empire's crumbling writ small.

There are a couple of other wonderful passages where Laura is out running errands and can practically hear the house calling her to dust upstairs or polish the silver. Any overworked homemaker is familiar with this omnipresent background mental stress.

Stephen’s world is not much better. He used to come home, wander around the garden and maybe “touch something up.” A real gardener did the hard work. Now most of that work is on him, and he has neither the training nor the time.

The garden becomes a source of genuine anxiety for him, as the house does for Laura. They drift along, each absorbed in a different set of worries. Nothing in their upbringing prepared them to face the empire’s decline together.

Panter-Downes captures that sense of decline beautifully in a scene at “the great house,” the kind of estate where the local aristocrats used to live and around which the village economy revolved.

Laura, who grew up there, visits on the day her remaining relatives are moving out because they can no longer afford the upkeep.

Laura is about to leave the big house, perhaps for the last time, to see her grandmother’s new “flat,” a converted cottage on the property. Before she goes, she notices how frail her aunt looks beneath the painting over the fireplace:

Her small figure looked lost in the great glowing room.... The group over the fireplace gazed down at her with well-fed, amiable arrogance, declaring that they were English ladies and gentlemen who would forever inherit the earth. Thus should life be, they said, the green garden and trout rising in the river.... Thus will life always be, stated their healthy confident faces. But in a minute there was nobody in the room but Aunt Sophia.

Laura then leaves and communes with nature in a way she never did when her social calendar was full of engagements no one can really afford anymore. After walking up a large hill and looking out over the village, she misses the obvious when she wonders why she never did this before.

She also connects a bit more with her daughter and later even with her husband, who is also trying to come to terms with his and England's reduced circumstances. While we don't know what his exact job is, it must be old-world respectable as he looks down on the richer "stockbrokers."

Yes, it’s the same “old money vs. new” cultural divide pushing people like Stephen and Laura aside, despite their belief in their own superiority. That superiority won’t cover the going rate for servants and gardeners. The stockbrokers, however, can pay it, so there is that.

One Fine Day evokes the Japanese concept of mono no aware – a bittersweet awareness of the impermanence of life, youth, and beauty.

By the end of the short novel, Stephen and Laura are close to making their peace with their reduced circumstances, knowing perhaps intuitively or subconsciously that their daughter Victoria is the real hope for the future.

Victoria carries none of the prewar memories of the world as it was. A shoddy garden, modest meals and a house without a full-time staff seem perfectly ordinary to Victoria. It’s all she’s ever known. She will forge England's post-empire future unburdened with memories of the empire's peak.

Panter-Downes captures small scenes or thoughts that reflect the larger forces at play. She also draws you into the characters’ lives by capturing the feel of an ordinary day in an ordinary family. It's almost a relaxing book until you realize how challenging their lives are.

Barbara Pym, Elizabeth Taylor, and several other authors tread similar literary ground as the "unwinding of the empire" is rich with stories of human struggles and disappointments. One Fine Day is an excellent short introduction to this style of fiction.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
115,903
Messages
3,201,190
Members
59,461
Latest member
BerniceDan
Top