The Wiser Hatter
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,765
- Location
- Louisville, Ky
[video=youtube_share;lkpWPRcAZbU]http://youtu.be/lkpWPRcAZbU[/video]
For the real dialect you need to watch 'Kes'.
I was born in Keighley, Yorkshire, and grew up until age 8 on Skipton Rd between the River Aire and the Leeds & Liverpool canal, so a lot of this little movie is very nostalgic for me.
But, I'll tell thee summat for nowt ....
Those mills were nowhere near as idyllic as the movie portrays: They were brutal places. Blake didn't use the phrase "dark satanic mills" for no reason. Whether they were Lancashire cotton mills or Yorkshire woolen mills, for a mill worker, riding their bike to work in the dark, cold rainy winter morning, clocking in for countless hours in the cacophonous bowels, then riding their bike home in the dark, winter rain again, was not a romantic existence; it was miserable drudgery that few can imagine these days.
And that lass playing Jane Eyre was not from Yorkshire, not with that accent.
Not to nit-pick, "Kes" was set in the mining area around Barnsley. The dialect is a bit different. At age 8, we moved to the Sheffield area (Dronfield, actually - you will know it estaban68) and I remember being misunderstood many times when I used the West Riding words. Hard to believe, huh? but true!
Anyway, the West Riding officially no longer exists. After at least a thousand years, the powers that be decreed it out of existence. There is West Yorkshire now, but it isn't the same area (smaller) than the West Riding was.
So how accurate was the dialect in All Creatures great and Small???
The last 6 or so generations of my family have been born and have lived in Yorkshire. We don't travel far! I love Yorkshire!
I don't know. I don't think I have ever seen the movie. But, this (from http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0071118/trivia?ref_=tt_trv_trv) makes me think it probably wasn't very accurate:
"Although born in Sunderland, Herriot spent the first twenty-three years of his life in Glasgow, and never lost the accent, as can be heard in television interviews. Simon Ward however, plays him as a Londoner."
Most TV shows seem to not be very accurate. The have people with Somerset accents in Lancashire, etc. "Downton Abbey" does a pretty good job with their Yorkshire accents, I think, even though Highclere Castle isn't in Yorkshire in real life. But, notice I said: accent. If the show's characters talked with a true dialect, you would probably need subtitles to understand what they said.
As esteban68 says, in 30 miles there can be a discernible difference in the accent. People can tell you're a stranger. TV and so forth is tending to lessen the differences these days, I think, but I don't live there anymore, so it's not really appropriate for me to try and comment authoritatively on how the UK's regional accents are holding up.
I was born in Keighley, Yorkshire, and grew up until age 8 on Skipton Rd between the River Aire and the Leeds & Liverpool canal, so a lot of this little movie is very nostalgic for me.
But, I'll tell thee summat for nowt ....
Those mills were nowhere near as idyllic as the movie portrays: They were brutal places. Blake didn't use the phrase "dark satanic mills" for no reason. Whether they were Lancashire cotton mills or Yorkshire woolen mills, for a mill worker, riding their bike to work in the dark, cold rainy winter morning, clocking in for countless hours in the cacophonous bowels, then riding their bike home in the dark, winter rain again, was not a romantic existence; it was miserable drudgery that few can imagine these days.
And that lass playing Jane Eyre was not from Yorkshire, not with that accent.
Not to nit-pick, "Kes" was set in the mining area around Barnsley. The dialect is a bit different. At age 8, we moved to the Sheffield area (Dronfield, actually - you will know it estaban68) and I remember being misunderstood many times when I used the West Riding words. Hard to believe, huh? but true!
Anyway, the West Riding officially no longer exists. After at least a thousand years, the powers that be decreed it out of existence. There is West Yorkshire now, but it isn't the same area (smaller) than the West Riding was.
I was just going through my late father's stuff. He started some ancestry research. Among the things there is a brief history of the Cawood name: My grandmother (dad's mum) was nee Cawood. The first record of the Cawood family name was in 935 AD, and the Manor of Cawood was given to the See of York by King Athelstan, grandson of Alfred the Great. So, I suppose half of my family didn't get too far from home for a millennium or so, too!