Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Of Sheep-Dip, Rot-Gut, and Furniture Polish. The worst of the worst.

LuvMyMan

I’ll Lock Up.
Messages
4,558
Location
Michigan
My experience with Australian wine is quite limited- I've had a few things which have been quite good. We have some horrid wines here in NY, but some really good ones too.

I don't understand why Yellow Tail was one of the wine selected for a big shin-dig that included some of our largest corporate and private donors. Aren't academics supposed to be wine snobs? Isn't that part of the stereotype? Why are we serving all these people who we are asking for money horrid wine? So they feel sorry for us and dig deeper in their pockets to buy us something decent to drink? That's going to backfire if they're sick on the wine.

Whenever I see a Yellow Tail box or bottle I have a involuntary shudder. I've been offered more free Yellow Tail wine since that date. Notice I didn't say I drank it. Urgh.

What does it actually taste like? Too bitter, slime,spoiled,old and nasty? Or is it just plain old cheap tasting?
 

earl

A-List Customer
Messages
316
Location
Kansas, USA
On behalf of Australia, I'd like to apologise for Yellow Tail wine ;)

We do produce some very nice wines, but Yellow Tail isn't one of them.
I find their Merlot preferrable to others I've tried in a similar price range and like their Shiraz-Grenache blend. Now, I don't venture into deep waters price-wise. So, have no experience with the pricier ones. But, for the $, these are pretty tasty.;) Earl
 

sheeplady

I'll Lock Up
Bartender
Messages
4,479
Location
Shenandoah Valley, Virginia, USA
What does it actually taste like? Too bitter, slime,spoiled,old and nasty? Or is it just plain old cheap tasting?

It's sweet, mainly, but the one I had was sweet yet astringent at the same time. It was an odd taste, kind of like spoiled fruit. I believe I had a white. Sweet whites (unless they are meant to be sweet, like a dessert wine) shock me.

It has it's reputations as a "palatable" wine. To be honest, I am not a wine snob. Basically there is little that I don't like. There's some things I really like.

I find their Merlot preferrable to others I've tried in a similar price range and like their Shiraz-Grenache blend. Now, I don't venture into deep waters price-wise. So, have no experience with the pricier ones. But, for the $, these are pretty tasty.;) Earl

It's a matter of personal preference. I'm not a wine expert- I'd put myself in the category of a novice. Yellow Tail has a reputation of being a novice's wine, and I found what I tried to not fit this novice's palate.

I really like Buttonwood Grove's Redbud wine (about $8), Knapp's Pasta Red (about $10), and Salmon Run's wines ($8 to $14) are always a good bet. Montezuma Winery's reds are also good and in a similar price range. I drink mainly NYS wine (buy local, support your local winemaker, etc., etc.) There are plenty of wines that are available for a similar price point if you are willing to experiment. I'm not sure if you have good wineries out in your area of the country, but I'd encourage you to try some local wines. There's probably some gems there you haven't discovered yet.

Again, to each his/ her own, but experiment!
 
It's sweet, mainly, but the one I had was sweet yet astringent at the same time. It was an odd taste, kind of like spoiled fruit. I believe I had a white. Sweet whites (unless they are meant to be sweet, like a dessert wine) shock me.

It has it's reputations as a "palatable" wine. To be honest, I am not a wine snob. Basically there is little that I don't like. There's some things I really like.



It's a matter of personal preference. I'm not a wine expert- I'd put myself in the category of a novice. Yellow Tail has a reputation of being a novice's wine, and I found what I tried to not fit this novice's palate.

I really like Buttonwood Grove's Redbud wine (about $8), Knapp's Pasta Red (about $10), and Salmon Run's wines ($8 to $14) are always a good bet. Montezuma Winery's reds are also good and in a similar price range. I drink mainly NYS wine (buy local, support your local winemaker, etc., etc.) There are plenty of wines that are available for a similar price point if you are willing to experiment. I'm not sure if you have good wineries out in your area of the country, but I'd encourage you to try some local wines. There's probably some gems there you haven't discovered yet.

Again, to each his/ her own, but experiment!

Fortunately I live in California. We don't produce bad wine---aside from Sutter Home. :puke: :p
 

sheeplady

I'll Lock Up
Bartender
Messages
4,479
Location
Shenandoah Valley, Virginia, USA
Fortunately I live in California. We don't produce bad wine---aside from Sutter Home. :puke: :p

I think they might add food coloring to their wines from the way they look in the stores...

NYS wines have really nice quality. I love the wine tent at the NYS fair. Had some excellent vermouth there (Atsby) from NYC last year- absolutely sublime vermouth. Couldn't get enough of it- will purchase some more this year if they are at the fair. Speaking of which, have to ask my liquor store to carry it.
 
I think they might add food coloring to their wines from the way they look in the stores...

NYS wines have really nice quality. I love the wine tent at the NYS fair. Had some excellent vermouth there (Atsby) from NYC last year- absolutely sublime vermouth. Couldn't get enough of it- will purchase some more this year if they are at the fair. Speaking of which, have to ask my liquor store to carry it.

You like vermouth?! :faint: :p I would put vermouth well within the confines of this thread. :p
Sutter Home is owned by a decent winery but they just produce junk with that label on it. I think they found a way to sell their rejects. :p
 

Renault

One Too Many
Messages
1,688
Location
Wilbarger creek bottom
I almost drowned in gin once. Wasn't pretty.

What about Retsina? Nice Greek wine. I seem to remember an evening of seafood and this wine while on Liberty one evening in Piraeus. Actually wasn't bad. But made for a pretty bad hangover!
 

1961MJS

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,370
Location
Norman Oklahoma
You like vermouth?! :faint: :p I would put vermouth well within the confines of this thread. :p
Sutter Home is owned by a decent winery but they just produce junk with that label on it. I think they found a way to sell their rejects. :p
I really dislike all vermouth that I've tasted. The three martinis I've had so far will be it, and me a James Bond fan too.

Later
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,295
Messages
3,078,191
Members
54,244
Latest member
seeldoger47
Top