Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

My experience with vintage.

Wild Root

Gone Home
Messages
5,532
Location
Monrovia California.
Over the last 9 or so years ever since I bought my first vintage fedora I had a natural feel for things of the past. Picking out suits and other vintage items came very easily. I have had only a little help when I first started to shop at vintage stores here in CA.

As I have collected I have noticed many things in the clothes I have. There are general rules to how to date a suit or “Estimate� the general age of a suit, slack, or shirt. Since 1996 to now I have learned a lot on my own about vintage suits. Mostly buy watching movies, wearing them, looking at old catalogs and original snapshots. As I have studded the different years it’s really quite something to learn that the more you know about vintage, the less you know about vintage I’ll elaborate, and dates in coats are one of the only true ways to date a suit. Now, there are other things that can be looked for to offer clues but, I have found some things aren’t always reliable.

The button fly pant:
Button flies have been on pants since they came around. When the zipper came into fruition in the 20’s it was a rather new and expensive way to fasten one’s pants. As the new idea became of age, it started to replace the button fly by the 40s. But, there are two sides to the coin! The button fly (Although more work and harder to make) was cheaper to make seeing that the metal zipper was not as cheap as vegetable ivory, bakelite, or glass buttons. So, I have seen button flies on pants all the way into the 50’s. I know they were 50’s because of the cut and the fabric of the slack. Also it depended on the personal preference of the customer.

Shoulder pads:
Most suits in the 40’s have reputation for having larger then life shoulder pads. The Hollywood drape models used this but most traditional tailors didn’t always embrace the new fashions. A man still could get a 30’s cut suit made in the 40’s. It always depended on the customer’s wishes. I have some suits I’d swear were 30’s but, to find a date that says to the contrary. Dates are your best friend for dating a suit.

Fabric:
The fabric of the 20’s 30’s 40’s and early 50’s were very close in relation. In the 20’s fabric was rather heavy as it was on through the next two decades. In the 20’s wool, linen, and cotton were the top choices. The 30’s saw the use of blends like Wool Casmir, wool cotton, and cotton or wool rayon blends. In the 40’s it was pretty much the same! Just as the 30’s had plenty of tweeds, worsted wools, wool rayon surge and twill, it didn’t change at all.

Cut: Traditionally in the 30’s pants were not very high waisted. They started to get higher waisted by the mid and late 30’s. Pants in the 30’s were some what wider but only with the collage youth of the time. Adults wore very conservative suits much the same look to that of the 20’s. In the 40’s the late 30’s look continued on till WWII. After the war that’s when the larger shoulder pads came out and very flowing drape like fit was in. But, must remember that the customer had a key in what his suit looked like. Most wanted to be modern and up with the times but there were older men who didn’t care for the new look or found it vulgar in some respects. I have on gray pinstriped double breasted suit that has a 1949 copy write union tag and you’ll swear this suit was made earlier! Has a true 30’s hourglass cut to the coat and the pants wear like an early 40’s pant. But, it’s from the early 50’s!

Details:
When looking for a particular vintage, I look for small details like suspender button placement, the coat lining, pocket placement, pleat style and so forth. This can often confuse me because some of the stuff that was started in the 30’s sill continued on into years after. If you find a suit with two inch cuffs and peaked lapels and think to your self that it has to be a 30’s suit you could be wrong. Thinking that some details were only used in years you read about is misleading and is a foolish way of thinking when looking at vintage. It may have a 30’s cut or look and you could wear it to pull of a 30’s look and that’s great but 3 out of 5 times it’s not always as old as you may like to think. Look at how there are lots of people still wearing 70’s and 80’s fashion today! The same was taking place in the Depression and the war years. Men liked to look sharp, but if a suit was still good why buy a new one? Only Hollywood and others in show business would have custom tailored suits to keep up with the times. And on that note it was mostly the studios who wanted it to be that way.

So, when you men and lads are shopping for vintage, be sure to feel the fabric look at the wear on the suit! Old suits have a patina if you will. They also have a smell you can’t mistake for a 60’s or 70’s suit. They will also weigh more then a later suit. Watch lots of black and white movies and also what ever Technicolor films you find from the 40’s. This will also help you a lot.

Good luck,

Root
 

flat-top

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,772
Location
Palookaville, NY
I have found that the fashion from the first half of each decade, is almost exactly the same as the second half of the previous decade. For example, post-war fashion sportswear is (mostly) the same as early to mid 50's. This is where my interests and expertise lie, and I'll tell ya, it's super difficult to really know specifically when certain things were made. It doesn't matter to me really, but I love when I find an ad in an old magazine for a shirt that I own! Suits and sportcoats, for me, I always try to find a date or a union label, because like Root said, you just can never really tell!
flat-top
 

sandysot

New in Town
Messages
43
Root:
Great post.
Many times the suits and jackets I see in the thrift stores have obscure tiny union labels and little else to date the material. Your tip about the union labels was excellent.Never really looked at them closely, although Ive noticed that some are cloth & black on white and some later ones are cloth/poly? but black on silver.

Do you know if there are any specific details on the labels that help to date the garment? Where would the date be located and what does it look like.Wonder what names unions used from one period to another.If they had different names at different times, it could be useful in dating.

Sandy
 

Wild Root

Gone Home
Messages
5,532
Location
Monrovia California.
Ok, this may help you out. When looking at the union tag, it would be paper or some sort of linen fabric tag on older suits. In 1949 it was a new copyright. In 49 an to the 50’s it was a fabric/paper combination tag.

You asked about labels, well there were many different brands that existed back then that are no longer around today. I’ll have to take some photos of them so you can get an idea. But, you can definitely tell the difference between and old label and a newer one. Old labels some times had designs and the fabric used in labels one can tell their old. They’ll have Reg. US. Pat Off in the corner or something to that effect. If you ever see the little wool swirl symbol then you know it’s not vintage! That little symbol came out in the 70’s. Most suits in my collection have a union tag and a tailor tag that will have a lot number, size, name, and date. Some times the tailor didn’t even fill this out. I have found blank tags and it always makes me upset that the tailor didn’t care to date his work. Labels most of the times were stitched with a cross stitch style that looks very classy. I would tell you some of the brands but you know, each suit you’ll find was made some place near of far away! And it’s mostly a custom made suit that was made by a tailor shop that no longer is around.

Polyester didn’t exist in the 30’s and 40’s. Do your self a big favor and find a vintage shop and ask to see a 30’s or 40’s suit. Even if it’s not your size just ask to see one and feel the fabric. Look at it closely and you’ll see the difference between a vintage suit and a modern suit. Compare the weight! Vintage beats modern in the heavy weight department! Watch movies from the 40’s! Not modern period films but the real deal! Study it till you can memorize the look. Remember they didn’t make clothes back then like they do today they made them to last and once you figure out the fabric thing, then you’ll be ahead of the game!

I can not stress this enough! Fabric, fabric, fabric! They had different colors then, and also different stripes, tweeds, and windowpane patterns. Get a book called “Every Day Fashions of the 1930’s� Also the next decades of the 40’s. These are clippings out of Sears catalogs and they will help you out immensely!

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/048625108X/102-5474980-3641729?v=glance

Root.
 

Angelicious

One of the Regulars
Messages
190
Location
Rainy ol' New Zealand
Wild Root said:
Polyester didn’t exist in the 30’s and 40’s.
Although you may find linings interesting...

As far as I have it, in the 30s and earlier jackets were generally lined with satin, made from silk. But in WWII, most of the silk was diverted to the military for parachutes, etc. Enter Rayon Acetate. :) Rayon is technically a man-made, but not really synthetic fibre (cellulose based, common from 1910). Acetate is a synthetic fibre.

If your jacket is lined with something that doesn't feel like silk, but is thicker, slipperier, but still soft and draping nicely, then your jacket probably dates from the mid 40s onward. :)

Great thread, by the way Root! :)
 

Wild Root

Gone Home
Messages
5,532
Location
Monrovia California.
Yes, rayon was around in the 40's! But, it was also used in the 30's as well! Silk was still a higher priced fabric and the higher priced coats had silk liners. And during the war rayon was used more then it was in the 30's. I really like rayon because it holds up better then silk.

Glad you're enjoying this thread!

Root.
 

Oscar Tong

Familiar Face
Messages
76
Location
Vancouver, BC, Canada
Thanks for all the great advice, Root! Now, would you mind elaborating on what you look for in the small details, such as suspender-button placement, the coat lining, pocket placement, pleat style, and so on? Thanks!
 

Wild Root

Gone Home
Messages
5,532
Location
Monrovia California.
Oh man, I was afraid some one was going to ask this. :p

Buttons in the 30's pants that I have found are some what farther apart. Also most of the time are on the out side part of the waist band.

Pleats were often shallower in the 30's. Not very deep as to the ones from the 40's and 50's.

Pant pockets were deep but not as deep as the 40's pockets.

Fit is also a key! 30's pants were cut closer to the hips and thighs then that of the 40's with a fuller cut before and after the war.

Hope that helps, ;)

Root.
 

flat-top

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,772
Location
Palookaville, NY
Also something guaranteeing that the suit is at least pre late 50's would be dropped belt loops on the pants. Unless of course it was a custom job. That style was completely out of style by the early 60's.
flat-top
 

Oscar Tong

Familiar Face
Messages
76
Location
Vancouver, BC, Canada
RE: Dropped belt loops

flat-top said:
Also something guaranteeing that the suit is at least pre late 50's would be dropped belt loops on the pants. Unless of course it was a custom job. That style was completely out of style by the early 60's.
flat-top
Dropped belt loops? Do you mean that they are sewn lower than usual or that they are absent?
 

flat-top

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,772
Location
Palookaville, NY
Ahh..I mean lower than regular belt loops! They are not right on the waistband. There is a thread here on the Lounge about Hollywood waisted pants that describes this style in more detail!!
flat-top
 

elsewhere

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
Southern California
For information's sake...

the Vintage Fashion Guild has collected information on the subject of union labels and other date-identifiers.
Here's the link, for reference.

http://www.vintagefashionguild.org/qt_labels.html

Under their label resource, you can also find a pic of the "Utility label" used in the UK during the war. More pictures of other labels are coming soon.. it's a work in progress... but I hope it's somewhat useful now ;)

(edited to add this link:)
Brief history of union mergers & tags--
http://www.vintagefashionguild.org/labels.php?labelno=147&mode=search
 

sandysot

New in Town
Messages
43
WidRoot wrote:
I can not stress this enough! Fabric, fabric, fabric! They had different colors then, and also different stripes, tweeds, and windowpane patterns. Get a book called “Every Day Fashions of the 1930’s� Also the next decades of the 40’s. These are clippings out of Sears catalogs and they will help you out immensely!

Root :
I ordered both books today plus a third one by Peacock on Patterns of the 40's.It shows the difference in patterns bofore WWI and then the changes to mens styles just after.Thanks for the tip.

Sandy
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,097
Messages
3,074,097
Members
54,091
Latest member
toptvsspala
Top