- Messages
- 16,822
I think some people tend to overhype and exaggerate the quality of super heavy hides over other lighter ones. I still have yet to find a vintage jacket from the 30-40s that has leather armor leather and it's not because they're broken in. The leather be it Horsehide, Pony, Goatskin, Steerhide and so on was definitely less thick and more pliable overall from my experience.
Depends. Cal Leathers has always been using extremely heavy hides, ever since they started out. Kinda stuff that's hard to match even today - especially today. I've heard people say they've had Cal and Bates jackets that made LW seem like a mall jacket and looking at some of those photos, I believe them. Granted, those are motorcycle jackets but yeah, heavy hides were used in jackets back then. Besides, many of those lighter vintage leather jackets we talk about here are the equivalent to what is today referred to as a "mall" jackets. I'm absolutely sure that made to measure jackets of the 50's were a lot heavier than your typical Californian.
And I believe that anyone who's ever sat on a motorcycle will always prefer heavier leather. That, I think, is a common fact. I never felt safe on a bike wearing even a medium weight jacket. This stuck with me and that's why I'll always prefer heavyass jackets. Same reason I don't trust goatskin much even tho makers swear on its superior performance during a crash. So yeah; heavy hides are proven to be tougher against whatever life throws at it and that's what I'll go with.