EL-Jimenez74
One of the Regulars
- Messages
- 273
- Location
- Fort Mill, SC
Appreciate the in-depth tasting notes. Amazing what a few drops of water can do to open up the different flavor profiles in a good whiskey. I'm more of a buorbon guys, as the "peatyness" of most scotch is just to smokey for me. Islays as a whole are generally not to my taste, but there are some Speysides that I have enjoyed. There was a Balvenie that I enjoyed, anyway thanks for sharing.This evening temps have dropped to 29'f (-2.0'c) so far. I have s c a m p e r e d about and enjoyed a couple of Surley IPA's. I have captured hood down and a hood up pics of me enjoying the IPA's.
A bit later tonight, the cooler temps had me motivated to sip a dram of Kilchoman Sanaig Cask Ilsay whiskey.
![]()
The APB is at 58%. The cool weather has me enjoying the effect of damping of the heat of alcohol and peat. Tonight the peaty smell is equaled by the sherry . The smell has fruit, licorice and a slight sulfurous note. On the taste it has me enjoying a dry sherry ,raisins, dry dates and finishes in blackberry, licorice and a peat (light sulfurous note). I really enjoyed this dram tonight. The cool weather has muted the alcoholic heat and the peat. It emphasizes the berry, smoke and licorice. Excellent sipping whiskey tonight.
I am recording in my whiskey notebook that the 28'f temps and the 42'f whisky dram temps had me enjoying the whisky for the above reasons. I have started to record my opinions and observations of my whisky sipping to get a better handle on my "likes and dislikes." Tonight I have started bringing an insta read thermometer to get some details of the drams I am enjoying. I will also record the different tastings with "drops" of water. The 42'f read tonight was based upon my reading of a cocktail book by ATK on martinis. They discussed the "correct" temps of a gin martini. In this reference iced and stirred to 42'f was a preference vs dilution by shaking or different (warmer/cooler) temps. I am curious if the dram temp and outside temps change my enjoyment.
No age statement means nothing to me as I like this whisky. This peated sherry cask strength whiskey is a pleasure to sip. Does it hold up to a Laphroig 10? I will have to try them side by side in the future.
Long post tonight. I am working to better understand what are my preferences and inclinations are.
Cheers, Eric -


