pigeon toe said:Actually, I find that my girdles take me WAY in at the hips and don't do much for my waist. I have a lot more fat on my hips and lower tummy (and not much at all on my waist), which I guess is quite easy to smush and flatten. My girdles usually bring my hips down about 3", and my waist only about 1". So it is possible depending on your body type!
That's why I mentioned my waist cincher. My girdle only takes in my waist 1-2inch, but about 3 on the hips. In my opinion, the girdle makes me look much thicker. I rarely wear it. The cincher pulls in my waist a good 3 inches (more on a puffy day) and none on my hips because it doesn't come down far enough. The waist cincher does a better job of giving me the 50's nipped waist look.