Fitcheck Fine creek leon 44 or 42. Which one should i choose.

[Hoanglong]

Hello everyone.
I'm really wondering whether to choose buy a fine creek leon custom jacket size 42 or 44. Please help me choose which one I should get. 42 seems a bit short-sleeved and a bit tight in the chest when fully zipped.
44 feels a bit wide to me
Im 5’9 and 165lbs
Thanks a lot.

 

[Leigh H]

The 42 fit is a very slim fit and looks too short in the arms for you.

I think the 44 will fit perfectly after its had some time to shape to your body and will be an overall better fit.

Has the 42 been worn for some time? it seems to have nice creasing in the arms compared to the 44 which looks almost like new.

Really depends how you like your fits.

 

[Peter Mackin]

Neither of them are very flattering on you if I'm honest.

 

[Hoanglong]

Neither of them are very flattering on you if I'm honest.

I understand, I just want to choose which jacket to buy

 

[Hoanglong]

The 42 fit is a very slim fit and looks too short in the arms for you.

I think the 44 will fit perfectly after its had some time to shape to your body and will be an overall better fit.

Has the 42 been worn for some time? it seems to have nice creasing in the arms compared to the 44 which looks almost like new.

Really depends how you like your fits.

yes 42 was worn by previous owner for about 2 years. it seems thicker than the 44.
Do you have any opinion on vertical length?

 

[Aloysius]

The 44 is too big in all dimensions, the 42 simultaneously looks too small and too big.

I would pass on both.

 

[Monitor]

I'm 100% with @Peter Mackin here. Neither look even half-decent on you, neither has a redeeming quality of any kind or sort and you have absolutely no reason to consider either. You deserve much better at any price tag.

While generally too large, the 44 is of a near-coat length while the 42 is so ill-proportioned I don't even know where to start. How it is at the same time too small while looking like a size 50 from the back is beyond understanding.

At the risk of sounding mean which isn't my intention, I would have extremely hard time keeping, while never reaching for, either, even if gifted.

 

[jchance]

Agree with others, both are not a good fit.

42: arm length too short, and body width too baggy—see the folded/scrunched up leather showing on the back, that’s way too much extra fabric.

44: arm length is fine but the body width is even worse and more baggy (same issue as above).

I’d get something else that fits if I were you. Otherwise, you’d regret it 6 months later after owning either one of these for some time.

I’m your height and weight (5’9, 160 lbs), asian/viet, and I wear a 40 in JP sizing. Not every brand from JP is flattering. Either shoulder too small or sleeve too short or chest-to-waist drop is too small.

 

[Canuck Panda]

42 looks fine.

The sleeves are shorter on this jacket. They were made this way to show off the watch. You wear a watch, so 42.

There is a thick deerskin version of this jacket, it drape better than the thick horsehide version imo.

 

[dudewuttheheck]

Neither of them are very flattering on you if I'm honest.

This. I don't think either looks great. They're both too long and too wide at the bottom. The 42 is too tight in the chest and the 44 looks loose.

 

[Monitor]

They were made this way to show off the watch. You wear a watch, so 42.

Lol! Are you just flat-out making this stuff up or did you actually hear that from some overzealous sales over at the Clutch cafe?

Why would you even say that!? It dead-on looks like a Thom Browne piece and if it isn't a Thom Browne piece, it has no business looking like that on anyone, ever.

 

[Aloysius]

As a watch guy I would definitely not want my watch sticking out, and that's before we get to the watch crime sprees that have become commonplace in so many cities.

 

[Hoanglong]

Thanks everyone for your comments.
I'll upload a photo of the back once the main zipper has been pulled out.
Actually the waist fits me. The chest also feels just right, but I don't understand why the back has so much extra fabric
My arms are longer than usual so it's quite difficult to choose a ready to wear jacket.
I often have suits tailored with a sleeve length of 25.2 inc.

 

[Aloysius]

Thanks everyone for your comments.
I'll upload a photo of the back once the main zipper has been pulled out.
Actually the waist fits me. The chest also feels just right, but I don't understand why the back has so much extra fabric
My arms are longer than usual so it's quite difficult to choose a ready to wear jacket.
I often have suits tailored with a sleeve length of 25.2 inc.

This doesn’t look like an improvement.

And to be clear I don’t even have a ln inherent problem with extra space/folds (what’s called drape in tailoring) but that’s not what’s happening here.

I think it’s cut extra big in the back and extra small in front because as @navetsea guessed some time ago, the magazine guys behind the brand design it to wear unzipped with untucked dress shirts, hence the weird shape and hems.