Fit Check Thread for Jackets

[WolfofStateSt]

The roughout shacket is short in the sleeves. But the big thing is that the sleeve opening is too wide for that rock star look. You could have it tailored and tighten at the wrist, but that's additional work and it's probably easier to just move it on.

The N-3A/N-3B in size Medium do have 35.5" nape sleeve length, but they wear shorter probably because the shrinking wool felt interlining and the knit cuff. However, when it comes to military clothing, I am much less critical about lengths or fit. As long as it's comfortable it's wearable.

The Ironheart pattern fit you very well. Stick with that and you don't have to worry about fit.

Yeah I might not even need a parka

 

[Eagledog]

I am a 19.5 in the shoulders but my sleeve measurements are usually 26, 27, 28. The suede jacket I posted yesterday was a 24 in the sleeves.

I have 17 " shoulder and 25.5" sleeve.
Ironheart works best in the non-custom world. Stick with that brand since it fits you. They have plenty of nice things to choose from.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

I have 17 " shoulder and 25.5" sleeve.
Ironheart works best in the non-custom world. Stick with that brand since it fits you. They have plenty of nice things to choose from.

There is something about the feel of their jackets, I love Real McCoys, but Iron Heart just feels so much heftier in hand, hard to describe.

 

[MrProper]

I am a 19.5 in the shoulders but my sleeve measurements are usually 26, 27, 28. The suede jacket I posted yesterday was a 24 in the sleeves.

I share the fate of the long arms. 19.5" shoulders, 28" sleeves are ideal. In a pinch, I'll also accept 27" lol

 

[WolfofStateSt]

I share the fate of the long arms. 19.5" shoulders, 28" sleeves are ideal. In a pinch, I'll also accept 27" lol

What are your go to brands then?

 

[WolfofStateSt]

I wonder which brand would make an N3A for my body type?

 

[MrProper]

What are your go to brands then?

My leather jackets are all made to measure. My fabric jackets (M-65, M-51, N-1) are from Helikon Tex, Brandit, Pike Brothers and Mil-Tec. I would also like the sleeves to be a bit longer, but it's just about acceptable.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

While we’re at this, is there any chance I could y’alls opinion on the fit of this WWII Peacoat?

 

[Eagledog]

Looks sharp. Except the sleeves are too short again. I had a Schott made in Canada and gave it away because of the sleeves being a few inches too short.

 

[Peacoat]

Looks to be a size or two too small for you. Sleeves are too short, body is too short and too tight, especially around the hips.

I have a guide that tells the prospective buyer how to get a good fit in a peacoat. It's in the Guides section.

 

[MrProper]

While we’re at this, is there any chance I could y’alls opinion on the fit of this WWII Peacoat?

Looks good, even if the sleeves are a bit short. If it were mine, I would have thick woollen knitted cuffs sewn in so that one or two cm peek out.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

Looks to be a size or two too small for you. Sleeves are too short, body is too short and too tight, especially around the hips.

I have a guide that tells the prospective buyer how to get a good fit in a peacoat. It's in the Guides section.

Thank you! I've been having a hard time finding a World War II peacoat that fits me well. This is the largest size I've found, but most of them seem a bit too small. Maybe people were smaller back then? If I can’t find one that fits, I’m seriously considering the Real McCoys 1913 peacoat, which feels a bit crazy. I usually don’t think about buying anything other than a leather jacket from those high-end brands, but I really love the World War One peacoat design; it’s my favorite and quite hard to find.

I appreciate your opinion because that coat has always felt a bit awkward to wear. I can barely fit an L.L. Bean sweater underneath it, let alone a chunky wool sweater.

 

[Peacoat]

My guide to getting the proper fit in a US Navy Peacoat is the first guide the Guide's section, which is at the top of the first page of the Fedora Lounge. It removes the hit and miss nature of getting a properly fitted peacoat. In the event you haven't seen the Guides section, below is the link. If you have a question, just ask. Let's keep it in the main peacoat thread, though.

https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/how-to-get-the-proper-size-in-a-us-navy-pea-coat.110255/

 

[WolfofStateSt]

My guide to getting the proper fit in a US Navy Peacoat is the first guide the Guide's section, which is at the top of the first page of the Fedora Lounge. It removes the hit and miss nature of getting a properly fitted peacoat. In the event you haven't seen the Guides section, below is the link. If you have a question, just ask. Let's keep it in the main peacoat thread, though.

https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/how-to-get-the-proper-size-in-a-us-navy-pea-coat.110255/

I have read your guide, but I bought this coat a while ago, before I became a member. I'm fairly certain about my size, but I think I need to give up on finding a true Navy Peacoat. I can’t seem to find one in my size that fits my height.

 

[Peacoat]

I have read your guide, but I bought this coat a while ago, before I became a member. I'm fairly certain about my size, but I think I need to give up on finding a true Navy Peacoat. I can’t seem to find one in my size that fits my height.

If you are 6' 2" or over, then it may well be a problem.

Go to our discussion the peacoat thread, give me your measurements, including your height, and I will try to help you out.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

If you are 6' 2" or over, then it may well be a problem.

Go to our discussion the peacoat thread, give me your measurements, including your height, and I will try to help you out.

I will take care of that! I’m between 6'3" and 6'4", so I usually tell people I'm 6'3" for sizing purposes. Some brands, like L.L. Bean and Carhartt, fit me well, but most others do not. I will move all my future comments about the US Navy peacoat to that thread. However, I might ask for opinions on the Billy Reid coat I have in this thread, since it's not technically a real peacoat.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

Like compare that USN Peacoat to this Billy Reid and which one fits better? I think it’s the Billy Reid.

 

[TartuWolf]

For sure the Billy Reid fits better, not solely because of the sleeve length.

 

[Edward]

I love that parka. Are the sleeves really that egregious?

It really ultimately comes down to what you're comfortable with in the end. They're shorter than I could live with, but that's me...

I'm also debating whether I actually need a parka, as the coldest it gets where I live is around -5 degrees Fahrenheit. I’m not sure if the Iron Heart Deck Jacket and a hat would be sufficient for that temperature.

I'm not one for definitive statements on what is necessary at certain temperatures, as we're all different: you'll find plenty of folks will queue up to tell you an Irvin or a B3 is "overkill for London Winter", but both proved ideal for me. Some folks find a longer winter jacket preferable to keep the spine end warmer on the go, or because they're wearing a blazer underneath, so it's all relative really. If the IH N1 is a good length for you and is heavy enough for you in that cold, though, it's definitely a good option.

 

[4444Design]

Thank you! I've been having a hard time finding a World War II peacoat that fits me well. This is the largest size I've found, but most of them seem a bit too small. Maybe people were smaller back then? If I can’t find one that fits, I’m seriously considering the Real McCoys 1913 peacoat, which feels a bit crazy. I usually don’t think about buying anything other than a leather jacket from those high-end brands, but I really love the World War One peacoat design; it’s my favorite and quite hard to find.

I appreciate your opinion because that coat has always felt a bit awkward to wear. I can barely fit an L.L. Bean sweater underneath it, let alone a chunky wool sweater.

It is indeed difficult to find wartime peacoats in a larger size - i manged to get one in 46 which is pretty snug on me (1.90 / 100 kg) even though it is a larger size but as long as there is no other option i will definately keep ...

I own a cheaper repop from STURM as well which runs larger - see pics for comparison


Original size 46

STURM repop size "L"