Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

ELC type A-2 Rough Wear 1401P

Jeremiah

A-List Customer
Messages
368
Location
Montana
Sweet Gav, very sweet & a great fit!!!! I like a bit of room too :)

Ordering a ELC Monarch ASAP and I will be sizing up (48) given previous experience of A-2 fit :)
I just got a Monarch New off the bay. Do you normally wear a 47? The Monarch I ordered was 40 but the measurements shown look like it will have a nice fit with some room to spare. My BK Dubow fits nice but is a little restrictive when I cross my arms or reach out. The Monarch has a little more room in that area of the shoulders. Also chest is 1.5" wider. The only thing I am a little nervous about with the fit is the back length is about 2.5" longer than my Dubow. But at that length it should have the nice look from Gav's jacket over the waist knits. Sleeves are 25" from my 23" on dubow which are short and when I reach out again they go past my wrist bone. A little annoying when driving. So we shall see.
 

bn1966

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,112
Location
UK
I just got a Monarch New off the bay. Do you normally wear a 47? The Monarch I ordered was 40 but the measurements shown look like it will have a nice fit with some room to spare. My BK Dubow fits nice but is a little restrictive when I cross my arms or reach out. The Monarch has a little more room in that area of the shoulders. Also chest is 1.5" wider. The only thing I am a little nervous about with the fit is the back length is about 2.5" longer than my Dubow. But at that length it should have the nice look from Gav's jacket over the waist knits. Sleeves are 25" from my 23" on dubow which are short and when I reach out again they go past my wrist bone. A little annoying when driving. So we shall see.

I'm a 46 but have quite broad shoulders, my RW 46 was a bit too snug & restrictive, sizing up in the Monarch will give me decent shoulder room & a little more space in the chest. I go between a 46 & 48 with ELC dependant on jacket cut :)
 

Gav

Practically Family
Messages
528
Location
UK
Don’t forget to post pictures when your monarchs arrive. I loved it when I tried it. I seem to remember it being trimmer than the RW but I could be confused.
 

bn1966

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,112
Location
UK
Don’t forget to post pictures when your monarchs arrive. I loved it when I tried it. I seem to remember it being trimmer than the RW but I could be confused.

Had a conversation with Rob: Bigger than the RW :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gav

Jeremiah

A-List Customer
Messages
368
Location
Montana
So you don't have to size up in the Monarch? Thats good. I was under the impression that the monarch was a trimmer (athletic) cut as well. Interesting.

EDIT: I went here and had a comparison of sizes. Check the roughwear 46 and compare to the monarch 46. once you click link, you need to check product measurements at top for both.

https://www.historypreservation.com...rough-wear-clo-co-1401-p-in-vintage-warhorse/

https://www.historypreservation.com...ying-jacket-monarch-mfg-co-contract-no-23378/
 
Last edited:

bn1966

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,112
Location
UK
So you don't have to size up in the Monarch? Thats good. I was under the impression that the monarch was a trimmer (athletic) cut as well. Interesting.

EDIT: I went here and had a comparison of sizes. Check the roughwear 46 and compare to the monarch 46. once you click link, you need to check product measurements at top for both.

https://www.historypreservation.com...rough-wear-clo-co-1401-p-in-vintage-warhorse/

https://www.historypreservation.com...ying-jacket-monarch-mfg-co-contract-no-23378/

Monarch gives an extra inch on the chest :) most generous cut on the 'Original Makers', tried the 48 on at ELC a few weeks ago...comfortable

Thanks for the link
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gav

Gav

Practically Family
Messages
528
Location
UK
I guess I was muddled. I tried on so many at the first pop up.... and so many times.
Last time I only had eyes for the RW.
 

bn1966

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,112
Location
UK
That RW is a beauty Gav, going 48 Monarch here just for a change & breathing space.
B-3 in November but a 46 (my chest size) as the 48 ate me :)

Spoke to Rob today at ELC, 'Pop Up' date & venue not confirmed yet for this year in Shoreditch.
 

Gav

Practically Family
Messages
528
Location
UK
I’d like to try a b-3 again. My 44 was too restrictive. I’m dubious about it being worthwhile for me though. I commute into London and it’s too warm on trains and tubes to wear a b-3.
My N-1 has served me well for years on the other hand so I may just stick with cloth jackets for winter.
 

bn1966

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,112
Location
UK
I’d like to try a b-3 again. My 44 was too restrictive. I’m dubious about it being worthwhile for me though. I commute into London and it’s too warm on trains and tubes to wear a b-3.
My N-1 has served me well for years on the other hand so I may just stick with cloth jackets for winter.

Sold my 46 Irvin which leaves a 'gap' (shoulders were a bit snug chest was OK), B-3 '50 Cal' in a 46 fitted a treat (wider shoulders) & would be worn when coldest... probably with only a T Shirt underneath. I have nice N-2B's & a minty N-2A should I want a nylon fix. Alpha B-15 covers 'beater' duties :)
 

Gav

Practically Family
Messages
528
Location
UK
A0F1FEAA-AD5A-470B-9194-D2936796ADD2.jpeg
Worn every (rainy) day since arrival. The character of the hide is beginning to show through.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,326
Messages
3,078,960
Members
54,243
Latest member
seeldoger47
Top