Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Ebay Hats: Victories, Defeats, Gripes & Items of Interest

ec145e36276e78f43a317faf0b4b7e6f.jpg

But are those X's authentic?

100x.jpg



Hold onto your knobs...

10000x.jpg
 

drmaxtejeda

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,354
Location
Mexico City
Found this item of interest (at the link below) and am curious exactly what constitutes 100x beaver v. 7x or 5x? At what point do the number of x's stop? I have searched on this forum for the definition but haven't found anything conclusive.
DISCLAIMER: I am not the seller of said item.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/El-Presidente-STETSON-Hat-100x-10k-Gold-Buckle-Set-7-3-8/323617721913
I have a Stetson El Presidente. It cost me $1000 dollars, brand new. It thought of it as my first "real" hat. I bought it because I am a fan of the TV show "Justified".
At the end of the last season I got a peek at the inside of Rayland Givens' hat. It was a Stetson 3X, and I figured a 100 X, like the "El Presidente" would be that much better, so I spared no expense.

Little did I know that Raylan's vintage 3X Stetson's felt was loads better than a modern 100 X felt.

When I took it to my hatter, Ignacio, to have him conform it to my head, he showed me how the felt was "bumpy". He made me feel it with my fingers, and then gave me a vintage 3X Stetson so I could feel the difference.

He also showed me how the El Presidente was covered with whitish talcum powder. I thought the powder was put there by Stetson to make the felt seem whiter, but Ignacio explained the powder hid the imperfections in the felt.
I had brushed the powder off before taking the hat to get conformed, so Ignacio had to sprinkle powder back on and then "rub it in", to make the El Presidente look better.
All this makes me wonder if the felt of a Stetson "Diamante", with a cost of $5000 dollars, is any good at all, but I am unwilling to spend so much to find out.

A much more reliable indication of the quality of a hat than the number of Xs on the sweatband is how much a hat cost in its day. After all, you couldn't sell a hat for fifty or a hundred dollars back then if the quality was poor, because consumers knew better.

That is why, not being a hat connoiseur, I started buying as many Dobbs "Twenty", Stetson, Dobbs, and Churchill "One Hundred", and Mallory "Fifteen" as I could find.

I also figured that a Borsalino "XXX" was better than a "XX", and that an "Extra Superiore" was better than a "Superiore", but Daniele Tanto, our Lounge Borsalino expert, has explained those are also marketing gimmicks, not to be relied on.

To top it all off, I recently bought a 1950s "John The Hatter" fedora on eBay for $59 bucks that turned out to have a way better felt than my modern $1000 dollar Optimos. It is also better than most of the older, true vintage hats I have acquired for ten times the price.

Very confusing and frustrating, I know. You literally have to feel your way through to get to know good felts.

Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

Just Daniel

One Too Many
Messages
1,451
Great summary, Doctor.

I agree with a big part of your assessment. Those old Stetson 3X hats from the 40s are my favorites I think, the Good to the Last Drop hats pre-plastic and pre-oilskin are sweet lids and lots of fun.

And discovering vintage hats from individual hatters sound amazing but dangerous! You will need a new safe just for them!!

Daniel


I have a Stetson El Presidente. It cost me $1000 dollars, brand new. It thought of it as my first "real" hat. I bought it because I am a fan of the TV show "Justified".
At the end of the last season I got a peek at the inside of Rayland Givens' hat. It was a Stetson 3X, and I figured a 100 X, like the "El Presidente" would be that much better, so I spared no expense.

Little did I know that Rayland's vintage 3X Stetson's felt was loads better than a modern 100 X felt.

When I took it to my hatter, Ignacio, to have him conform it to my head, he showed me how the felt was "bumpy". He made me feel it with my fingers, and then gave me a vintage 3X Stetson so I could feel the difference.

He also showed me how the El Presidente was covered with whitish talcum powder. I thought the powder was put there by Stetson to make the felt seem whiter, but Ignacio explained the powder hid the imperfections in the felt.
I had brushed the powder off before taking the hat to get conformed, so Ignacio had to sprinkle powder back on and then "rub it in", to make the El Presidente look better.
All this makes me wonder if the felt of a Stetson "Diamante", with a cost of $5000 dollars, is any good at all, but I am unwilling to spend so much to find out.

A much more reliable indication of the quality of a hat than the number of Xs on the sweatband is how much a hat cost in its day. After all, you couldn't sell a hat for fifty or a hundred dollars back then if the quality was poor, because consumers knew better.

That is why, not being a hat connoiseur, I started buying as many Dobbs "Twenty", Stetson, Dobbs, and Churchill "One Hundred", and Mallory "Fifteen" as I could find.

I also figured that a Borsalino "XXX" was better than a "XX", and that an "Extra Superiore" was better than a "Superiore", but Daniele Tanto, our Lounge Borsalino expert, has explained those are also marketing gimmicks, not to be relied on.

To top it all off, I recently bought a 1950s "John The Hatter" fedora on eBay for $59 bucks that turned out to have a way better felt than my modern $1000 dollar Optimos. It is also better than most of the older, true vintage hats I have acquired for ten times the price.

Very confusing and frustrating, I know. You litterally have to feel your way through to get to know good felts.

Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk
 

drmaxtejeda

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,354
Location
Mexico City
Great summary, Doctor.

I agree with a big part of your assessment. Those old Stetson 3X hats from the 40s are my favorites I think, the Good to the Last Drop hats pre-plastic and pre-oilskin are sweet lids and lots of fun.

And discovering vintage hats from individual hatters sound amazing but dangerous! You will need a new safe just for them!!

Daniel
I bought the "John" because I have a "Tropp" that I bought from Moon. Both have similar liners, and I was curious to see if John's were as good as Tropp's.
John's is even better, and that's saying.
35df8ced549c51864c84b2b7df260207.jpg
746ed6c343471fe8313d391c57924b3d.jpg


Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk
 
Messages
18,401
Location
Nederland
I bought the "John" because I have a "Tropp" that I bought from Moon. Both have similar liners, and I was curious to see if John's were as good as Tropp's.
John's is even better, and that's saying.
35df8ced549c51864c84b2b7df260207.jpg
746ed6c343471fe8313d391c57924b3d.jpg


Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk
Mystery hats are great for just that reason, Max. They usually can be had cheap and sometimes the quality is just stellar. What could be better than that?
 

Steinbockhase

Practically Family
Messages
514
Location
Munich, Bavaria, Germany
Great summary, Doctor.

I agree with a big part of your assessment. Those old Stetson 3X hats from the 40s are my favorites I think, the Good to the Last Drop hats pre-plastic and pre-oilskin are sweet lids and lots of fun.

And discovering vintage hats from individual hatters sound amazing but dangerous! You will need a new safe just for them!!

Daniel

Here is a current eBay offer for a Stetson 3x Stetsonian in great condition.
If shipping were not so exspensive (46 $ to Germany) I would buy it.
Maybe someone closer to Texas is interested.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-19...h=item4b5b4ab980:g:52IAAOSwxtVb~Zhj:rk:9:pf:0

stetsonian.jpg
 
Messages
19,001
Location
Central California

drmaxtejeda

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,354
Location
Mexico City
Just bought this one. I don't really know if Super-Lux Swan's Down Portises are rare, but it's the first one I've seen, and I really like the ribbon.
Besides, it was only 50 bucks.
P.S. If anyone asks about that dark rectangle at the back of the hat, I'll just say it's a military rank mark.

16f61c539e3a50a5b4271f4facb130f7.jpg
2a289a56fc75fe2f3120f6c6e488b97e.jpg
1453bb943ecd2080927618c8727057f5.jpg
0db68787a5c3991df4610afcac313d3f.jpg
829f0246eaefd440a5d7f0a3ca18e47f.jpg
fdaed4da5d40a2bdd307f7c57eea9f8e.jpg
f8c5a6a6681d2c7abceb45219497343b.jpg
3bf81e1c83af44e6b710d15e8beaeccc.jpg
73042d7f9e9deab5c4748c8c3c184fac.jpg


Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Messages
19,001
Location
Central California
Just bought this one. I don't really know if Super-Lux Swan's Down Portises are rare, but it's the first one I've seen, and I really like the ribbon.
Besides, it was only 50 bucks.
P.S. If anyone asks about that dark rectangle at the back of the hat, I'll just say it's a military rank mark.

16f61c539e3a50a5b4271f4facb130f7.jpg
2a289a56fc75fe2f3120f6c6e488b97e.jpg
1453bb943ecd2080927618c8727057f5.jpg
0db68787a5c3991df4610afcac313d3f.jpg
829f0246eaefd440a5d7f0a3ca18e47f.jpg
fdaed4da5d40a2bdd307f7c57eea9f8e.jpg
f8c5a6a6681d2c7abceb45219497343b.jpg
3bf81e1c83af44e6b710d15e8beaeccc.jpg
73042d7f9e9deab5c4748c8c3c184fac.jpg


Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk

That ribbon treatment is nice.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,097
Messages
3,074,088
Members
54,091
Latest member
toptvsspala
Top