- Messages
- 12,021
- Location
- East of Los Angeles
The real problem with The Black Dahlia is that it's based on the novel of the same name written by James Ellroy--a crime fiction novel that uses the discovery of Ms. Short's body as not much more than a plot device. To make matters worse, director Brian De Palma edited the movie's initial cut in order to reduce it's run time from three hours to two, which resulted in the final version being somewhat incoherent.Yes, 2006. What's frustrating is that they had the technical material to create a great visual of the time period. I'm not sure why the producers had to install a soap story of the two lead characters. The events of the "Black Dahlia" felt as an add-on or after thought. Without a good screenplay or acting this movie appears to have been produced by folks using straws.
Titanic movie. Same thing!
I agree with your comparison to Titanic. "Hey, let's take a tragic yet compelling real-life event and add a bunch of phony baloney fictional elements to it!"