Thank you I really appreciate the feedback. I also have the AE Park Avenue and they fit perfectly so I guess that's what I'll order. I'm glad you like them. If they are more comfortable than my Park Avenues I'll probably never take them off.My Higgins Mill boots fit true to size. My Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxfords are 11E, my Higgins Mill boots are 11E. For me, the Higgins Mill are a little more comfortable than the dress shoes, as my feet lean a bit wide. My boots are in brown Chromexcel and I really, really like them. I like the ankle support, I like the fact that they breathe. With wool socks they are warm, with cotton socks they are cool. With the Chromexcel, they are very substantial, if that makes any sense. Understated, yet substantial. They are in my regular rotation.