Planning on sending my Lost Worlds chain mail armor jacket off for a new zip once it arrives this week and I'm toying with the idea of using a vintage NOS Talon #5 two way zip. Mainly for aesthetics. Would you guys chance it or stay with the #10 it was built with?
-
The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
#5 Zipper on Heavy Hides?? 4 oz
- Thread starter jpk_NJ
- Start date
Sheepdog149
Practically Family
- Messages
- 622
- Location
- Fort Lauderdale, FL
-- I'd definitely consult with Stuart, of LW, as he's a wealth of information...
Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk
- Messages
- 16,848
My LW vest originally had a smaller Talon zipper - same one in the product info photos on lostworldsinc.com - which literally shattered (the previous owner kept the broken zipper in the chest pocket) and was replaced with a gigantic paperclip Talon which to me seems to be just about the only possible choice for the kind of leather LW is using.
I personally wouldn't take a chance of having anything smaller than the #10 zipper installed into any seriously heavy leather jacket.
Featured products
-
Alden 403 Moc Toe Boot - Brown Chromexcel - $680 The classic "Indy" style Alden Boot in the classic Horween brown Chromexcel. -
Grant Stone Diesel Boot Dark Olive Chromexcel - #395 Goodyear welted, Horween Chromexcel, classic good looks. -
Himel Bros. - The Ross Mk. 1 Leather Jacket Classic D-pocket motorcycle/aviator style jacket.
My LW vest originally had a smaller Talon zipper - same one in the product info photos on lostworldsinc.com - which literally shattered (the previous owner kept the broken zipper in the chest pocket) and was replaced with a gigantic paperclip Talon which to me seems to be just about the only possible choice for the kind of leather LW is using.
I personally wouldn't rick having anything smaller than the #10 zipper on any really heavy leather jacket.
Seconded, #5 zips were not designed for these heavy hides. Which zip do you currently have on and which jacket is it?
Harris HTM
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,890
- Location
- In the Depths of R'lyeh
All my Aero's have this tiny talon. Especially with my Long Half Belt, which is a beast (https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/new-aero-long-half-belt-shearling-lined.89578/), every time I zip it I (mentally) cross my fingers...
Stay with the big fella.
Stay with the big fella.
photo2u
Call Me a Cab
- Messages
- 2,358
- Location
- claremont california
Hi, I would go with a military talon type. I think they can do they job well. Also, who is doing the zipp work? It is not easy to do. Please let me know if you have a good craftsman who can tackle the job. I am always interested in knowing them.
You can find NOS military zippers in eBay. If you do not find one, let me know, I have a good stash that can share with a forum member.
Look at this link attachments. It might give you an idea. https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/the-lost-world-j23-project.95455/
Good luck with your project friend,
G.
You can find NOS military zippers in eBay. If you do not find one, let me know, I have a good stash that can share with a forum member.
Look at this link attachments. It might give you an idea. https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/the-lost-world-j23-project.95455/
Good luck with your project friend,
G.
El Marro
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,602
- Location
- California
My 4oz+ LW has a #10 NOS Conmar zipper and I get nervous zipping that thing up sometimes! No way I would chance anything smaller on an LW jacket.
My 4oz Aero Steerhide j106 obliterated every single #5 on the jacket. That said my nearly 5oz halfbelt hasn’t broken the teeny tiny 5. If I had a choice I wouldn’t want anything less than an 8 on something that heavy. It’s not a matter of if, it’s a matter of when, it will break.
I'd never use any zipper marked as YKK on any good repros 'cause that's the exact mass-market brand which almost ruined old good american zippers like original Talon. YKK was cheaper but not better. Still looks cheapo to me. That's why. YKK? Nope, never. Just not my cup of tea.
Any other zipper might suit Ok, but not YKK anyway.
If persist on YKK - well, at least it should be marked like Talon or something just to look Ok on repros, but not marked as YKK which looks just horrible to my taste, esp. on any good repro from 30s-60s.
Riri isn't quite period correct - well, yes. But it anyway looks much much more neutral and still works and feels better than YKK which is the zipper brand I always try to avoid on my jackets.
Just a personal opinion and personal choice.
Any other zipper might suit Ok, but not YKK anyway.
If persist on YKK - well, at least it should be marked like Talon or something just to look Ok on repros, but not marked as YKK which looks just horrible to my taste, esp. on any good repro from 30s-60s.
Riri isn't quite period correct - well, yes. But it anyway looks much much more neutral and still works and feels better than YKK which is the zipper brand I always try to avoid on my jackets.
Just a personal opinion and personal choice.
Last edited:
- Messages
- 10,631
it is cheap, but on my jacket it has not failed yet or showing sign of failing for 5 years on the oldest, I don't like the square default pull, I always use their paperclip style, but obviously not looking repro
I agree. I need to count on my zips when riding. YKK reliability is why I do not mind using them. Do I prefer a monster Talon? I guess I do, but a YKK10 works extremely well, so YKK work for me.
strange thing YKK rivets and denim button are praised to be the best and often mentioned in the spec of a premium jeans,
their default rectangular puller for metal autolock zip is a poo poo design , but I don't mind their paperclip, ykk antiqued brass also patina copper red on the edges, however I stay away of their chrome/ nickle puller as the metal looks ugly, unless you find their rather rare antiqued silver/ gunmetal pull ( i bought dozen of it from ebay to replace puller/ slider of silver YKK on my jacket).
and often mentioned in the spec of a premium jeans, their default rectangular puller for metal autolock zip is a poo poo design , but I don't mind their paperclip, ykk antiqued brass also patina copper red on the edges, however I stay away of their chrome/ nickle puller as the metal looks ugly, unless you find their rather rare antiqued silver/ gunmetal pull ( i bought dozen of it from ebay to replace puller/ slider of silver YKK on my jacket).
Davidm
Familiar Face
- Messages
- 75
- Location
- Netherlands
YKK zippers are bad. I mean i had quite a few on my "fashion" stuff like Stone Island etc, and they always fails after few years. And my repro talons on Buco and GW survived 10+ years. and i never had a single issues with them. Sold those jackets, but i think there is few more decades to come with no issues. Crown on LW is superb as well.
- Messages
- 10,631
Like all brands, there are tiers to YKK zippers.
- Messages
- 6,462
- Location
- South of Nashville
A #10 is a good choice for that jacket. My tiny Aero zip (#5?) failed after a year or so of problems. I contacted Allan at Johnson about putting a #8 on it. He said they always use #10 for their jackets and doesn't recommend anything smaller. He put a #10 on it, and I have had no further problems. As Stu made your jacket, he is the one to contact. I imagine he put a #10 on it for a very good reason, and will probably laugh at your wanting to swap out for a #5.
- Messages
- 16,848
Exactly.
The fact that a clothes company opts to go with the cheapest YKK's doesn't mean a thing and anyone saying "YKK is bad!" should take a look at their top tier zippers. They make stuff that's every bit as good and pretty as anything else out there.
I mean, just check out their repro line. Literally every vtg style there was.
https://www.ykkfastening.com/products/search/detail.html?pdid1=OLD+AMERICAN(R)
