Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Cafe Racer, roomy fit, and layering: is it possible?

MCM_92

New in Town
Messages
7
Hello gentlemen,

I'm fairly inexperienced, so I'm trying to get a better understanding of what's achievable in terms of fit across different models and intended uses.
Are café racer styles, layering and a boxy fit mutually exclusive? I'd like to order a CCT-1260 from Thedi, but use it as a winter jacket: with added detachable lining and measurements that would allow me to wear a sweater underneath as well.
Is that something you think is achievable, or does that particular cut only really work when worn close-fitted?
 

zebedee

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,143
Location
Hong Kong
You can size up to do this - Thedi cuts are tight and close so definitely take your measurements while you are wearing what you'd wear in winter (and then add an inch...).
 

jerryoldiee

New in Town
Messages
18
MCM_92, to add to Zebedee's point: take your measurements with the detachable lining in, since it eats into chest and sleeve room. Check the armhole and bicep too, not just chest, because a sweater usually makes a close cut feel tight there. Shoulders are hardest to fix later, so keep those true to a fit you like and add the extra room in the chest and body. Get final measurements confirmed in writing before the deposit.
 

MCM_92

New in Town
Messages
7
Thanks, guys. I hadn't considered the sleeves and biceps, so I'll keep all of that in mind. The removable inner liner would also be made by Thedi, so it would be up to them to adjust the jacket's measurements accordingly to accommodate that.

Is it actually feasible in principle, though, or will I end up looking like a box on two legs? I've spent hours browsing the forum but haven't come across a single picture of a café racer worn this way. Am I trying to do something that's never been done before?
 

zebedee

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,143
Location
Hong Kong
Thanks, guys. I hadn't considered the sleeves and biceps, so I'll keep all of that in mind. The removable inner liner would also be made by Thedi, so it would be up to them to adjust the jacket's measurements accordingly to accommodate that.

Is it actually feasible in principle, though, or will I end up looking like a box on two legs? I've spent hours browsing the forum but haven't come across a single picture of a café racer worn this way. Am I trying to do something that's never been done before?
I have the grim situation of being the kind of oblong body shape that suits an Aero Highwayman in 40 and a Maxwell in 42. The shape I am does not suit an Aero Café Racer 40 (tee hee) and can just about fit a 42 (on broccoli, swimming, etc. With a t-shirt. Only). A 44 CR is my jam, though. I can stick a hoodie under it, wear it with a t-shirt, and so on. Is it slightly 'big'? Oui. Is it boxy? Un peu. Is it all-around more useful to me in hot, cold, rainy, boozy, pork pie eating weather? Oh yes. Yes it is. And it's fine over a shirt.
Photo on 27-12-2023 at 5.41 PM.jpeg
 

raf

A-List Customer
Messages
306
When layering under leather jackets, I've come to greatly appreciate the (relatively cheap) US Army Surplus Flame Resistant EWOL fleece jackets. Earlier versions were not flame resistant, but also cheaper. FR units will specify majority "Aramid" fiber content or specify majority Nomex fiber content--same thing. No label, no idea about fiber contents. One color suits all, that currently being "Foliage Green" (not unlike ancient USAF "Sage Green", and later on other colors might have been added, such as "Coyote Brown". The sewn-in fiber content tag will tell the tale regardless of color.

I've had fleece garments ruined by nearby smokers and campfire embers. No longer.

Typical GI sizing chart can usually allow a user to confidently down-size One chest size and have a decently fitting fleece jacket. Sometimes a "snug" fit can be had by downsizing Two chest sizes; these fleece jackets are a little stretchy. The "correct" GI sizing charts will reveal Short/Reg/Long user height guidelines.

In my experience, one should always heed the official GI height guidelines unless one's body/arms is/are radically different from the norm. IMHO, going a little bigger is usually more comfortable than going a little too small.

All said, I've given away nearly all of my fleece jackets except my marvelous North Face Denali fleece jackets all bought for pennies on the dollar at local thrift store.
 
Last edited:

AeroFan_07

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,264
Location
Iowa
@MrProper - 4-pocket CR was a similar fit to my 4-pcoket CR that I had for ~ 6 years and then sold in 2020. i bought it off the rack in Thurston Brother's store in Seattle, which is now all online. I have never owned a Thedi, but the 4-pocket Aero CR works pretty well with a sweatshirt under it. What I will say is the Board Racer is totally different. It is tight, tubular and a true racing shirt fit & design. So that may not be the direction you want to go.
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,162
Location
Europe
I mean, I hear you and I know I too would find some fault with a jacket that fit me like this but that jacket fits you perfectly.
Yeah, sometimes I think I shouldn't have sold it. But honestly, it was too short for me, and I hardly ever wore it anymore.
Right now, though, I'm back to preferring slightly looser jackets, so it wouldn't be a bad choice again ;)
I've gotten a little tired of my other leather jackets and am currently wearing almost nothing but my Fashion CWU 45.
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,162
Location
Europe
@MrProper - 4-pocket CR was a similar fit to my 4-pcoket CR that I had for ~ 6 years and then sold in 2020. i bought it off the rack in Thurston Brother's store in Seattle, which is now all online. I have never owned a Thedi, but the 4-pocket Aero CR works pretty well with a sweatshirt under it. What I will say is the Board Racer is totally different. It is tight, tubular and a true racking shirt. So that may not be the direction you want to go.
You probably mean @MCM_92 in your post, right?
 
INTRODUCING THE #HERITAGE2026 CONTEST
Introducing the #Heritage2026 contest by Reversible!

If you’re anything like the textbook Fedora Lounge reader, you’ve already got a few outfits up your sleeve that could earn you a $100 cash prize. So show us what you’ve got.

REVERSIBLE is giving you the chance to win $100 by sharing your best heritage-inspired looks.

There are 10 winners: 4 selected based on the most-liked posts and 6 handpicked by the Fedora Lounge, Styleforum & Heddels teams.

HOW TO ENTER:

1. Sign up on the REVERSIBLE app: https://styleforum.co/4iYurFm

2. Create a post on the REVERSIBLE app, and tag #heritage2026.

That’s it! Show us your denim, boots, workwear, and everything else that makes heritage style your own.

Good luck and happy posting!

- The Fedora Lounge Team

Sponsored Content

Forum statistics

Threads
115,869
Messages
3,200,661
Members
59,432
Latest member
dkdt8888888
Top