Edward
Bartender
- Messages
- 25,084
- Location
- London, UK
In the original drawings, Rorschach's suit / trenchcoat and hat all looked to me like an 80s take on the 40s look, as if someone had made an attempt to recreate a Bogie look from what was available in the shops at the time. Actually, the trechcoat he wore is very Bogie in that it cuts off just on the top of the knee - a few inches shorter than the norm (I'm sure I read Bogies were deliberately tailored that way to give him the illusion of greater height in the coat).
I had had the hat down as a Fedora with a stingy brim - a cut-down Federation would be ideal. Seeing those photos from behind, where the film-hat's top is visible, it definitely has a porkpie-style telescopic crown. The narrow Brim also says pp to me - actually, the pp look with a wide ribbon and front dents is pure Sinatra to my eyes. My Akubra Rap (Akubra's own PP design), which I have to hand, is fairly close were it to be in their dark brown (as opposed to black), though a [slightly[/i] lower crown than the one in your photos, and with a bound, not raw, edge. The ribbon is also a little narrower, if I'm being uber-picky. Seems to me that if your really want ot get as accurate as possible from a new hat, a trimmed-brim and appropriately-bashed Federation in Dark Brown (possibly with a wider ribbon) is the closest you'll get without getting into a custom lid.
I've loved Rorschach's costume ever since I first discovered Watchmen - it was very nearly this Halloween's option, but I was so keen to do a Baseball Fury and U ran out of events to fit the extra costume! Thinking of attending an early screening of Watchmen in costume, though....
I had had the hat down as a Fedora with a stingy brim - a cut-down Federation would be ideal. Seeing those photos from behind, where the film-hat's top is visible, it definitely has a porkpie-style telescopic crown. The narrow Brim also says pp to me - actually, the pp look with a wide ribbon and front dents is pure Sinatra to my eyes. My Akubra Rap (Akubra's own PP design), which I have to hand, is fairly close were it to be in their dark brown (as opposed to black), though a [slightly[/i] lower crown than the one in your photos, and with a bound, not raw, edge. The ribbon is also a little narrower, if I'm being uber-picky. Seems to me that if your really want ot get as accurate as possible from a new hat, a trimmed-brim and appropriately-bashed Federation in Dark Brown (possibly with a wider ribbon) is the closest you'll get without getting into a custom lid.
I've loved Rorschach's costume ever since I first discovered Watchmen - it was very nearly this Halloween's option, but I was so keen to do a Baseball Fury and U ran out of events to fit the extra costume! Thinking of attending an early screening of Watchmen in costume, though....