Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Best A-2 goatskin I've seen so far anywhere.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dahlan Netsch

New in Town
Messages
15
I've had, handled, worn, photographed and owned many WWII jackets, but the new SMW goatskin A-2 is the best I've seen. Needless to say it has all the dead-on details that you would expect from SMW and fits like a glove. But the quality of the leather is it's best attribute. They say they only pick 25 out of every 100 skins they examine and I believe them. But don't take my word for it, check it out yourself at https://www.smwholesaleusa.com/shop-us View attachment 185045
 
Last edited:

Dahlan Netsch

New in Town
Messages
15
Can't help that. I'm a professional copywriter and photographer. But that doesn't mean what I wrote about this particular jacket isn't true. I handle and shoot 100s of products but this is the only one I have put up on this thread. Although, I have to admit there are others I feel as strongly about, like SMWs USMC "Pacifiic" HBTs and camos, and their new USN deck jackets.
 
Last edited:

Seb Lucas

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,562
Location
Australia
Well, sorry but what you have written reads like the standard hokey copy you might read on a website. It doesn't read like a spontaneous customer providing some feedback. Could be that's just years of writing bad habits coming out by accident. I've got to ask: you here to influence the Lounge?

I actually like Steve's A2's. Is the same guy in Mexico still making them? He was good.
 

Carlos840

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,944
Location
London
I've had, handled, worn, photographed and owned so many WWII USand German jackets that I have no idea how many of them I've had. But the new SMW goatskin A-2 is the best so far. Needless to say it has all the dead-on details that yoiu would expect from SMW and fits like a glove, but the quality of the leather is way way better than all others. They say they only pick 25 out of every 100 skins they examine and I believe them. But don't take my word for it, check it out yourself at https://www.smwholesaleusa.com/shop-us View attachment 185045

Could we please have a fit pic of yours? Just to see how they fit and how the leather drapes?
 

Carlos840

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,944
Location
London
I've got to ask: you here to influence the Lounge?

What makes you think that?

j23Shth.png
 

Seb Lucas

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,562
Location
Australia
Too funny (and too obvious)

Problem for me is it has the opposite effect. When I think people are being disingenuous with me I won't engage with what they are selling, even if I had been interested.

Let me try one:

You know what fellows? As a collector of fine leather jackets, I've found a superlative product, along with a wonderful deal for you. The good folk at Leather Astonishers use the highest quality leather in the world to give you not only the best fit imaginable, but a drape so nice it's like being in the sensual embrace of a supermodel. You've got to try it on to believe it. Buy one. It won't be your last.
 

Carlos840

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,944
Location
London
Too funny (and too obvious)

Problem for me is it has the opposite effect. When I think people are being disingenuous with me I won't engage with what they are selling, even if I had been interested.

Let me try one:

You know what fellows? As a collector of fine leather jackets, I've found a superlative product, along with a wonderful deal for you. The good folk at Leather Astonishers use the highest quality leather in the world to give you not only the best fit imaginable, but a drape so nice it's like being in the sensual embrace of a supermodel. You've got to try it on to believe it. Buy one. It won't be your last.

Wait it gets better!
How stupid does this guy think we are?
(have a look at the facebook, so much cringe its funny...)

Se7wYGH.png
 
Last edited:

Dahlan Netsch

New in Town
Messages
15
I didn't post the above ATF and SMW ads on this forum. They were screen captured completely out of context from my Facebook business page and put here to impune my opinion. My earlier statement about deck jackets was refering to SMW's new N-1 and their 1st model blue jacket NOT the ATF deck jacket above. I photographed Navy deck jackets for both ATF and SMW and SMW's is clearly the most authentic. I know because I actually had one when I was in the Navy (albeit in very poor condition) when I served in the mid 60s. So you ask if I am trying to influence this forum, I can only say that I am adding my opinion to the forum. My experience as a seasoned adman, journalist and combat veteran.
 
Last edited:

Dahlan Netsch

New in Town
Messages
15
I'll take that as a compliment that you like my work. You're just being a Bartender Edit: language! trying to impune my opinion by stating the obvious that I am a professional adman. I stated that right up front.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Seb Lucas

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,562
Location
Australia
What part of "I handle and shoot 100s of products but this is the only one I have put up on this thread"?

You may well be a nice guy, so please take this just as constructive feedback and not as a scathing attack, although I can't control how you take things.

Your first post was clumsy - more so given what has come out since. Maybe if you had provided better information about your context rather than a mere few words of "I handle and shoot..." Coming on big about a product's wondrous status in somewhat dead advertising language is bound to raise eyebrows and get us speculating about context. You sounded a series of false notes that seemed pretty funny.

I'm sorry you didn't have a laugh along with us and you might well have bonded with us over this. I am more than happy for you to start again without prejudice and maybe you can tell us more about why suddenly you seek to elevate Macca's work which I am a fan of already.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Dahlan Netsch

New in Town
Messages
15
I cannot believe that someone has used the term 'wanker' on here. In fact, scratch that comment about A-2s and just think for a second on 'wanker'.

Handling and shooting products is probably of less use than actual fit pics when making claims about quality. The same could, presumably, be said of onanism.

Fit shots are by no means a qualitative discription of fit. Fit can easilly be enhansed by using good body models. (Actually, I prefer shooting model shots in good lifestyle situations) but this category of apparel vendors rarely spend the money to achieve that level of production value. Detail shots are the most practical and affordable way of showing product attributes.
 
Last edited:

Carlos840

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,944
Location
London
What part of "I handle and shoot 100s of products but this is the only one I have put up on this thread"?

Mate, come on!

@tmitchell59 has "handle and shoot 100s of products", so have many other users on this forum, still they don't try to sneak in some advertising by pretending they are being good to us and giving us insider tips.

You tried to be sneaky, you got caught, accept it and move on...
The only way you are getting out of this is by showing us your well loved, nicely worn goatskin A-2 that you love so much!

Actually i have found a picture on your facebook page that is perfect for this occasion:

OuWw0yv.png
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
109,127
Messages
3,074,661
Members
54,105
Latest member
joejosephlo
Top