Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Review: Real Simons Californian 1940

MadCat

One of the Regulars
Messages
270
I would rather have an Aero than a Japanese or Chinese jacket (partly because I like to support UK manufacturing, partly because I just really like the jackets and the patterns work for me) but I'd say the real objection to the Chinese makers for a lot of people, including me, is that the supply chain is just not something I feel comfortable supporting with my money. The denim is slave labour cotton and I can't imagine anything else made at too-good-to-be-true prices are a barrel of laughs either.

For me, that's the main reason I don't want to buy these products (even if, in some cases, the designs do appeal).
The device you used to write this was made using “slave labour” lol.

I’m not into Chinese jackets either, but like I said in my post, I just wanted to see how good this jacket is. And it is good. I’ll wear it. Just like i’ll wear my Nike sneakers made in China and type from my phone that’s made in China.
 

nirvana42

Familiar Face
Messages
78
The device you used to write this was made using “slave labour” lol.

I’m not into Chinese jackets either, but like I said in my post, I just wanted to see how good this jacket is. And it is good. I’ll wear it. Just like i’ll wear my Nike sneakers made in China and type from my phone that’s made in China.
I think it's more about reducing purchases of goods using exploited labor, the best one can, especially for luxury items. It's definitely harder to do with modern necessities like smartphones. The best way is probably second hand purchases to avoid directly contributing to companies that exploit labor. And even if buying from countries like the US, Japan, UK there's still a decent chance of exploitive labor being used (e.g. LA and NYC sweat shops), but it's probably less likely than China, India, etc.
 

MadCat

One of the Regulars
Messages
270
I think it's more about reducing purchases of goods using exploited labor, the best one can, especially for luxury items. It's definitely harder to do with modern necessities like smartphones. The best way is probably second hand purchases to avoid directly contributing to companies that exploit labor. And even if buying from countries like the US, Japan, UK there's still a decent chance of exploitive labor being used (e.g. LA and NYC sweat shops), but it's probably less likely than China, India, etc.
Here is their factory tour. I don’t see 6 year olds sitting in a crowded dirty environment slaving away at a sewing machine. It’s a bunch of Chinese women doing the work in a normal factory setting. Chill.

 
Last edited:

Arin666

Familiar Face
Messages
75
Nice jacket. Could you share the specific product link on the BH website for this one that you purchased?
 

gjchristy

A-List Customer
Messages
316
I think these look like they’re really nice jackets, but the $600 price tag gives me pause. I’m gonna spend that much money, I would probably just pony up some extra to get a real heritage brand. But that’s just me. Having said that, I am tempted. I almost purchased their J 100, but the crush on retro was about $130 less so I went for that instead. No regrets, although I’m sure I would’ve loved the real simons version.
Do you know the maker of the J100 you got? Post some pics.
 

JonS1967

Practically Family
Messages
838
Location
San Diego
Do you know the maker of the J100 you got? Post some pics.
It’s Veluokldly brand, full waxed aniline leather and the lining is a cotton-poly blend. Here are a few photos.
DJI_20260312_082939_509.jpeg
IMG_0836.jpeg
IMG_0839.jpeg
IMG_0840.jpeg
IMG_0838.jpeg

IMG_4157.jpeg
 
Last edited:

JonS1967

Practically Family
Messages
838
Location
San Diego
The leather looks really nice. The arms appear to be a little fat compared to racers. What say u?
The arms are a bit fatter than some of my other jackets, but it doesn't bother me at all. What impresses me about this jacket is that there are no small pieces of leather on the under side of the arms or on the sides of the jacket. It's made like my Lewis Leathers Dominator in that regard.
 

gjchristy

A-List Customer
Messages
316
The arms are a bit fatter than some of my other jackets, but it doesn't bother me at all. What impresses me about this jacket is that there are no small pieces of leather on the under side of the arms or on the sides of the jacket. It's made like my Lewis Leathers Dominator in that regard.
Nice! My Velo Cross Zip has very nice leather like yours. I wrote a review on it. I think these makers are really coming up in the world. I have had a few China sources projects for my business and found the leather work (Watch Travel Cases) very good.
 
Messages
11,139
Location
My mother's basement
Just yesterday I ordered from Brake House the same jacket as MadCat’s, but in black. With the discount code it came to only 481 bucks and some-odd cents all-in — shipping, taxes, the whole shebang.

Brake House emailed the order confirmation right away as well as another followup to verify size, asking for height, weight, “regular” jacket size, etc. This is confidence inspiring.

I’m far from expert in such matters so I kinda lean on the better versed. Reading around suggests that for a person looking to part with something under four figures (well under, in this case; I could have bought two and still come in just under a grand) the Real Simons from Brake House seems worthy of serious consideration.
 

MadCat

One of the Regulars
Messages
270
Just yesterday I ordered from Brake House the same jacket as MadCat’s, but in black. With the discount code it came to only 481 bucks and some-odd cents all-in — shipping, taxes, the whole shebang.

Brake House emailed the order confirmation right away as well as another followup to verify size, asking for height, weight, “regular” jacket size, etc. This is confidence inspiring.

I’m far from expert in such matters so I kinda lean on the better versed. Reading around suggests that for a person looking to part with something under four figures (well under, in this case; I could have bought two and still come in just under a grand) the Real Simons from Brake House seems worthy of serious consideration.
I think you’ll be very happy with it.
 

short_lefty

Familiar Face
Messages
61
You don't have to let perfect be the enemy of good. Clothing is an easy win - none of us have to own this stuff. It's one of the few areas of life where sticking to your ethics is actually really easy, especially if you're willing to use places like Vinted and eBay.

(that's not to say I judge people for taking up these bargains - you're right that there's an element of hypocrisy there and people can decide what they're comfortable with, it's none of my business. I'm just making the point that there's a difference between the Japanese/European makers and the Chinese options)
"You don't have to let perfect be the enemy of good" is such a terrible excuse when you can just look within and realize you're virtue signaling. Don't want to get into it, but your morals aren't consistent. not everything from China is slave labor and you assume there isn't explosive labor elsewhere?

You can also very very very easily get an android or a used phone. There is 0 reason for you to use "slave labor". Or is slave labor ok as long you can use the latest apple tech?
 
Last edited:

Arin666

Familiar Face
Messages
75
Just yesterday I ordered from Brake House the same jacket as MadCat’s, but in black. With the discount code it came to only 481 bucks and some-odd cents all-in — shipping, taxes, the whole shebang.

Brake House emailed the order confirmation right away as well as another followup to verify size, asking for height, weight, “regular” jacket size, etc. This is confidence inspiring.

I’m far from expert in such matters so I kinda lean on the better versed. Reading around suggests that for a person looking to part with something under four figures (well under, in this case; I could have bought two and still come in just under a grand) the Real Simons from Brake House seems worthy of serious consideration.
Did you receive the jacket yet?

If so - what has been your experience with it ? Any initial impressions you can share?
 

short_lefty

Familiar Face
Messages
61
I think it's more about reducing purchases of goods using exploited labor, the best one can, especially for luxury items. It's definitely harder to do with modern necessities like smartphones. The best way is probably second hand purchases to avoid directly contributing to companies that exploit labor. And even if buying from countries like the US, Japan, UK there's still a decent chance of exploitive labor being used (e.g. LA and NYC sweat shops), but it's probably less likely than China, India, etc.
This slave labor is ok because it is convenient for me. But this slave labor is not! this is the arguement you are making.

When did smartphones become a necessity? can you dial it back to where slave labor is not in the equation?

Also, just because there is explotive labor in china (and across the world) does not mean every single maker and person in the country abuses that. Id argue that real Simons uses less explotive labor than apple. How do you think they keep prices at insanely low levels ?
 
Last edited:

nirvana42

Familiar Face
Messages
78
This slave labor is ok because it is convenient for me. But this slave labor is not! this is the arguement you are making.

When did smartphones become a necessity? can you dial it back to where slave labor is not in the equation?

Also, just because there is explotive labor in china (and across the world) does not mean every single maker and person in the country abuses that. Id argue that real Simons uses less explotive labor than apple. How do you think they keep prices at insanely low levels ?
I'm not making any such argument. Smartphones and other computers are modern tools/necessities, whether you accept that reality or not. People require them for day-to-day tasks and work across different fields, whereas leather fashion jackets aren't used in that way. And the unfortunate reality of the making smartphones and other computers is that you won't find an equivalently made product to say a Schott jacket, which is made by union labor with materials made by union labor too (e.g. Horween). That's why I made note of buying secondhand.

You're also building up a straw man, I never said every maker in a given country is using exploitive labor. I agree with you, you'll find varying degrees of labor standards within a country, but ultimately those labor standards are set by a country's labor laws, and I trust the laws and enforcement of those laws in countries like Japan, US, the UK, than say India, China, Pakistan.
 
Last edited:

short_lefty

Familiar Face
Messages
61
I'm not making any such argument. Smartphones and other computers are modern tools/necessities, whether you accept that reality or not. People require them for day-to-day tasks and work across different fields, whereas leather fashion jackets aren't used in that way. And the unfortunate reality of the making smartphones and other computers is that you won't find an equivalently made product to say a Schott jacket, which is made by union labor with materials made by union labor too (e.g. Horween). That's why I made note of buying secondhand.

You're also building up a straw man, I never said every maker in a given country is using exploitive labor. I agree with you, you'll find varying degrees of labor standards within a country, but ultimately those labor standards are set by a country's labor laws, and I trust the laws and enforcement of those laws in countries like Japan, US, the UK, than say India, China, Pakistan.
"I think it's more about reducing purchases of goods using exploited labor, the best one can, especially for luxury items. It's definitely harder to do with modern necessities like smartphones." What does this imply? Are smartphones not a luxury item that you can EASILY replace? Or do you need the apple duo to have fedoralounge on one screen and emails on the other?

Even if you deem smartphones as a necessity (they are not) you are indirectly supporting and participating in the exploitation because.....?? Then ask if that is justified.

What I was trying to convey was that just because China/Asian countries would likely have more explotive labor practices than European/American companies, does NOT mean that companies like Real Simons have lower standards than a "Made in Italy" or In America product which is what it seems like what was being aruged. As you agreed with, there are nuisances to everything and therefore should not automatically assume more virtue by buying a made in Europe / American product than made in an Asian country without further research.


Here's a recent cool video of Clutch Magazine Founder reviewing Real Simons. Key item being that the price to quality ratio was surprising

 
Last edited:

nirvana42

Familiar Face
Messages
78
"I think it's more about reducing purchases of goods using exploited labor, the best one can, especially for luxury items. It's definitely harder to do with modern necessities like smartphones." What does this imply? Are smartphones not a luxury item that you can EASILY replace? Or do you need the apple duo to have fedoralounge on one screen and emails on the other?

Even if you deem smartphones as a necessity (they are not) you are indirectly participating in the exploitation because.....??

What I was trying to convey was that just because China/Asian countries would likely have more explotive labor practices than European/American companies, does NOT mean that companies like Real Simons have lower standards than a "Made in Italy" or In America product which is what it seems like what was being aruged. As you agreed with, there are nuisances to everything and therefore should not automatically assume more virtue by buying a made in Europe / American product than made in an Asian country without further research.


Here's a recent cool video of Clutch Magazine Founder reviewing Real Simons. Key item being that the price to quality ratio was surprising

No, smartphones and other computers are not luxury items whose utility can easily be replaced in modern society. Many aspects of our day to day lives require the use of some kind of computer, with smartphones being the most accessible kind of computer for the average person. Whereas leather fashion jackets, are very much luxury items, whose utility can be easily replaced. Either can be had secondhand, if you so desire, to avoid concerns about monetarily contributing to companies that may exploit labor.

If you want to keep discussing how the utility of smartphones and computers is or isn't easily replaceable, feel free to mail me a letter next time. :)
 

CriscoPisco

New in Town
Messages
18
Location
San Jose
Even if one is willing to look past questionable labor practices, the jackets themselves do not hold up, at least visually. The body always looks elongated and bloated, sleeves always look to short, leather looks dull…. For me personally, I can’t think of a single reason to invest any amount of money in one of these jackets. Do they look terrible? No. Do they look good? Also no.

Far too many better options at equivalent (or nearly equivalent) price points. Particularly in the abundant barely worn market.
 

short_lefty

Familiar Face
Messages
61
No, smartphones and other computers are not luxury items whose utility can easily be replaced in modern society. Many aspects of our day to day lives require the use of some kind of computer, with smartphones being the most accessible kind of computer for the average person. Whereas leather fashion jackets, are very much luxury items, whose utility can be easily replaced. Either can be had secondhand, if you so desire, to avoid concerns about monetarily contributing to companies that may exploit labor.

If you want to keep discussing how the utility of smartphones and computers is or isn't easily replaceable, feel free to mail me a letter next time. :)
You Completely ignored the core of my replies. so just because smartphones and computers are core to your life, it is justifiable to participate in the explotive labor practices overseas?

No need, I'll end it on that note for you to contemplate yourself if you choose to do so.
 
INTRODUCING THE #HERITAGE2026 CONTEST
Introducing the #Heritage2026 contest by Reversible!

If you’re anything like the textbook Fedora Lounge reader, you’ve already got a few outfits up your sleeve that could earn you a $100 cash prize. So show us what you’ve got.

REVERSIBLE is giving you the chance to win $100 by sharing your best heritage-inspired looks.

There are 10 winners: 4 selected based on the most-liked posts and 6 handpicked by the Fedora Lounge, Styleforum & Heddels teams.

HOW TO ENTER:

1. Sign up on the REVERSIBLE app: https://styleforum.co/4iYurFm

2. Create a post on the REVERSIBLE app, and tag #heritage2026.

That’s it! Show us your denim, boots, workwear, and everything else that makes heritage style your own.

Good luck and happy posting!

- The Fedora Lounge Team

Sponsored Content

Forum statistics

Threads
115,931
Messages
3,201,724
Members
59,481
Latest member
Gmoney
Top